My vote goes to @king-ragnar.
The way I see it, Deathstroke has superior strength and skill, whereas Daken has a superior healing factor. Deathstroke has better reaction timing, but they should be roughly equal in combat speed and durability. Both have the means to easily slice and stab the other.
KR relied a lot on lifting strength though, which I don't think is as relevant as striking strength in a fight. He also seemed to equate piercing durability to damage soak by saying how Deathstroke wouldn't be affected by being stabbed. A good thing he did was highlight the limits of Daken's HF.
Payne heavily relied on outliers for Daken, such as hurting Thing with a punch and being able to harm Skaar, using fights against high-tiers as a comparison. This seriously harmed his credibility in my opinion. He also brought up the stealth aspect, which I thought was pretty irrelevant, and something Slade is much superior in anyways.
Basically, it comes down to Slade's superior strength and skill vs. Daken's healing factor. KR convinced me that Slade holds enough of a skill advantage over Daken that he could dismember him and/or stab his brain, thus removing the advantage of the healing factor.
This was a really quick and fun CaV to read! Great job to the both of you!
Log in to comment