Comic Vine News

121 Comments

Off My Mind: Why Scott Snyder's Reveal in BATMAN #10 Makes Sense [SPOILERS]

Spoilers. If you haven't already read the issue, do so now. History is changing but it's actually something that was already established in the previous continuity.

No Caption Provided

Hopefully you've read BATMAN #10 by now. Since the "New 52" started, we've seen Bruce Wayne dealing with a long hidden mystery in Gotham City. He thought he knew everything about the city but soon discovered the existence of the Court of Owls.

The Court stemmed from an old nursery rhyme. After Thomas and Martha Wayne were killed, Bruce wondered if there was more to their deaths than a simply mugging. Investigating the possibility of the existence of the Court of Owls lead him to the conclusion that they did not exist. This was an error that would soon come back to haunt him.

In the first nine issues of BATMAN, we've had mystery after mystery. Revelations have been sprouting left and right but none have been as huge as the one in issue #10. We now know the answer to the question of who has been behind a lot of the recent events.

This revelation changes the history of the Waynes as we thought we knew it. Scott Snyder made a bold move in firmly establishing this as an official part of Batman's mythos. This is why it makes perfect sense.

Final warning: there will be spoilers below!

== TEASER ==

The idea that Bruce Wayne had a brother, Thomas Wayne Jr. isn't a new concept. Those opposed to the idea of Bruce having a brother can't accuse Snyder of changing history because it's an idea that was established. Only nothing was ever really done with it.

The main source for Thomas Jr.'s existence is WORLD'S FINEST #223 from 1974. Batman was on the hunt for the Boomerang Killer. Along with Superman and Deadman, Batman was determined to find the killer. Deadman, inhabiting a civilian's body, managed to follow the killer to an apartment. When Batman and Deadman entered, they found a notebook with the name, Thomas Willowwood.

No Caption Provided

Deadman pointed out that Willowwood was the "upstate funny farm." Willowwood was also the name of the facility in BATMAN #10. Obviously there would have to be a reason for a patient at Willowwood to have that name as their surname as well. When Batman (and Deadman) visit the sanitarium, the doctor informs Batman that he can't give him access to Thomas Willowwood's records but is able to tell him that he escaped about a year ago. As for why his last name was Willowwood, the doctor informs them that Thomas came to them as a child and the name was used because his family name is a secret.

With Deadman able to inhabit people's body's, he jumps into the doctor's after Batman says there's no time to get a court order. As much as Batman dislikes using these methods, the killer is still on the loose. He reads that Thomas arrived there as a small child and was insane from injuries resulting from severe trauma after a car accident.

No Caption Provided

It's unfortunate that Thomas is still disturbed. It turned out that he was being used to kill others. The real killer convinced Thomas that the victims were enemies that were out to get him. Thomas seemed to have disappeared but what happened was Deadman took over his body and left. With Deadman in "control" of Thomas' body, innocents couldn't be harmed and Deadman had a new body for himself.

What doesn't make sense is the very next story in the same issue makes no mention of Deadman taking over Thomas Jr.'s body. He's back to his normal routine of randomly taking over people in order to get to the bottom of things. What ever happened to this Thomas Jr.?

No Caption Provided

Of course this isn't the only Thomas Wayne Jr. we've seen. In the reverse world of Earth 3, Thomas Wayne Jr. exists as Owlman and is part of the Crime Syndicate of Amerika. It was made that Owlman was Thomas Wayne Jr. in JLA: EARTH-2, published in 2000.

The character, Owlman, in the Crime Syndicate is meant to be the opposite of Batman. You could say he's his dark reflection. But this isn't simply an evil Bruce Wayne.

Owlman is actually Thomas Wayne Jr. on his world. Instead of Thomas Sr. and Martha getting killed, it turns out that Martha and Bruce were murdered. Thomas Jr. blamed his father for their deaths and became Owlman while Thomas Sr. became the commissioner.

The key here is the fact that Thomas Wayne Jr was Owlman, totally fitting considering Lincoln possibly being Thomas Wayne Jr and his connection to the Court of Owls.

No Caption Provided

In other words, Snyder didn't simply re-write history and introduce a (possible) brother to Bruce Wayne just for shock value. The existence of Thomas Jr. already existed. For whatever reason, absolutely nothing was done with it. Bringing him back could have been done by anyone. Thankfully and obviously Snyder put deep thought into how to make it work and work so well.

We'll have to keep reading to see how these events play out. Bruce doesn't fully believe the confession but he was wrong about the Court's existence in the first place.

121 Comments

Avatar image for batshrine
batshrine

1081

Forum Posts

146

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

Edited By batshrine

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

@Xtremesteve said:

I'll give you THREE reasons why I disagree with this being good story-telling for Batman...

1. IT BREAKS THE ARCHETYPE: Batman being the only son wasn't by accident. The only orphan son as the chosen one happens in literature all the time (Moses, King Arthur, etc.) and is classical in style. Now usually I wouldn't mind shaking things up but in this case you are...

2. USING A CLICHE to replace the Archetype. The Evil-Twin/Dark Brother has also been done a hundred times. DC does this trick to delirium (Bizarro, Reverse Flash, etc) and it only subtracts from the lone wolf mentality of Bruce Wayne. Ultimately this...

3. DEFIES THE SINGULARITY. Put simply, Bruce Wayne is LESS unique in the DC universe if there is someone just like him running around... Batman stacks with Superman because Batman is in fact a Super Man. He is the pinnacle of human drive... and now it just so happens we have TWO of him... which kind of not only makes his origin achievement less amazing but also perhaps genetically pre-determined?

There have been stories of 'evil Batmans' told in the past. The idea has been explored. Making it canon doesn't create a dichotomy, it deteriorates a novelty....

Well said. Snyder's Batman is terribly derivative.

I agree with your second two points, but your first one being an archetype, really shouldn't matter. It just makes for easier story telling to be honest. And Moses had 2 siblings, and one step-sibling (the evil one). But as far as keeping Batman unique, I am all for that.

Avatar image for edtie97
edtie97

81

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By edtie97

All I could say after reading this issue is wow!!

Avatar image for entropy_aegis
entropy_aegis

21789

Forum Posts

420

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 7

Edited By entropy_aegis

My problems with the execution of this story still persist.

What exactly is the history of the COO? Snyder has made absolutely no effort here.He introduced the Court as faceless rich guys and then kills them off in the same manner.

How did they rule Gotham and yet chose to attack virtually everyone from the Waynes to Penguin to Freeze to even the corrupt mayor?I mean should'nt the corrupt guys have been under their pay roll?

Why did they choose to strike at this moment?

I'm all for one proper evil twin and Owlman(there are too many between Hush,Wrath,Hurt and various Owlmen across the multiverse) but not like this.No G-Man the reveal does not make sense because it makes the Waynes look like they were sociopaths and also cause the reveal had virtually zero build up.There was no surprise here,Lincoln is introduced in #1,gets injured in #2,heals in#3 and gets killed by #9 and then is revealed as the "TEH MASTERMIND",screams like Hush to me.

And seriously what's the point of shoehorning the Court in to every aspect of Batman's life?

Avatar image for savagedragon
SavageDragon

2257

Forum Posts

200

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

Edited By SavageDragon

@Xtremesteve: Unless Thomas Jr dies, or is just crazy and isnt related.

Avatar image for savagedragon
SavageDragon

2257

Forum Posts

200

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

Edited By SavageDragon

@entropy_aegis: Well there is still one issue left in the arc and Ive heard the issue after that will tie up some loose ends. So hopefully your questions will be answered in the next two months. I think explaining more and more about "how" the court worked will take away their mystique. They should remain somewhat of a mystery in my opinion. There is also that Talon book coming out so I'm sure there will be a lot of interesting info about the court in that book.

Avatar image for mostxtremebrian
MostXtremeBrian

2

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MostXtremeBrian

@Maybeland said:

I have a problem with the magically appearing Waynes of Snyder and Morrison.

I'll give it to Snyder for keeping it down to one and making the reveal 10 issues instead of 60 spread out over 3 different titles.

But doesn't this all seem a little soap opera-ey to anybody I mean I was shocked that March didn't have an eyepach, a mustache, and Amnesia!

I'd also argue that this reveal is way too repetitive of what Snyder did with James Jr. in Black Mirror.

Can we get a Batman book that doesn't involve trudging up evil relatives out of thin air( or 40 years ago).

That's just it man, comic books ARE soap operas, with superheroes thrown into the mix. Sure, there are some that transcend the genre, but that's why we love them, for the insane twists and who-slept-with-who.

Avatar image for dangermart
dangermart

162

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By dangermart

One thing about Lincoln March being the ultimate bad guy - it was a bit obvious ... he's the only major new character, so really the only suspect. It's like when there's a number of guest stars in Law & Order and one Really Rather Famous person - you can jolly well bet theydunit. When March apparently died  last month it was pretty guessable that he wasn't going to be 'dead' long.

Avatar image for sevangrim
SevanGrim

2192

Forum Posts

8056

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 49

User Lists: 9

Edited By SevanGrim

I still have a strange feeling that Jarvis Pennyworth has a part in this...

Avatar image for supbatz
SupBatz

2186

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By SupBatz

The idea has precedent. That in itself doesn't necessarily mean it "makes sense" or is a good idea.

I'm on the fence about the whole Thomas Wayne Jr. thing. I agree that it felt incredibly cliche when I finished reading Batman #10. And I was very much reminded of Thomas Elliot's backstory. And (here comes the bias) I don't think I'm too keen on having a baby brother thrown into the mix after all of this time.

I'm going to wait until the end of the whole COO arch before I make a final decision but one thing I'm sure of is that I vastly prefer everything that I've read in Batman and Robin to anything I've read in Batman lately.

Avatar image for erikmcalister
ErikMcAlister

45

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 1

Edited By ErikMcAlister

@Gylan Thomas said:

@DarthShap said:

Great twist indeed. Loved it. :)

I loved Morrison's run but most people who did not kept saying that he was using too many obscure references to past comics. Now let's see how these people react when Snyder does it and expressly reference a Morrison idea.

Also, it just goes to show how much that whole "the New 52 is for new readers" was BS. ^^

I'm one of those who didn't like Morrisons run.

It wasn't that he was using obscure things from the old continuity but rather the way he did it. I still prefer Snyders writing.

I have to agree that I didn't like his run either. I may even go as far as to say that he is a little overrated -- I'm not saying it right now, but I may say it at some point.

Avatar image for gracetrack
Gracetrack

5283

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Gracetrack

@Gylan Thomas: Agreed. It's not that Morrison used obscure references, but how he used them. His writing can be very good, but it can also be very convoluted and meta (e.g. RIP, Final Crisis).

Avatar image for gracetrack
Gracetrack

5283

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Gracetrack

Batman vs. Owlman, it'll be one for the ages.

Certainly going to be an issue to really showcase what Bruce can do. He's basically fighting an undead evil version of himself who can regenerate, and who is wearing a power suit that probably augments his strength. Can't wait to see some amazing battle feats. :)

Avatar image for xtremesteve
Xtremesteve

25

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Xtremesteve

Moses wasn't the best example, although it's arguable that he would still be considered having an only child background while being raised as essentially adopted Egyptian royalty. That isn't important. I could give you countless examples that prove my point from Jesus to Calvin and Hobbes. Further, your argument that an archetype is 'easy storytelling' is self defeating because Synder using a cliche 'evil twin' in its place is also 'easy storytelling'. You missed my point that Bob Kane undoubtedly placed the archetype in purposely to add legitimacy, classical styling, and identifiable structure for the reader. BOOM!

Avatar image for zombietag
zombietag

1699

Forum Posts

1807

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 2

Edited By zombietag

snyder is awesome! this is very cool, good article.

as for people saying this is cliche, get over. on a lot of levels, everything is cliche. no ones ever really going to write a "brand new story" everything has been done at one point or another. the point is, snyder is doing an amazing job telling the story.

not to mention, it hasnt been proven that it really is his brother...

Avatar image for masterdetective
MasterDetective

1500

Forum Posts

193

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MasterDetective

wait a sec, Batman has a brother?

Avatar image for kadosho_16bit
kadosho_16bit

77

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By kadosho_16bit

I always had the feeling that Watchmen wasn't some parallel project. But in fact part of the Batman (and DCU) mythos for a reason. Crossing those boundary lines in storytelling will definitely be an interesting challenge to see unfold.

Avatar image for the_fallen11
the_fallen11

642

Forum Posts

26

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

Edited By the_fallen11

I think this is pretty cool, if Lincoln March IS TWjr. I would be okay with it...I think it would be a better idea if Lincoln WASN'T Tom jr. And was just brainwashed into thinking he was, I think it would just make Lincoln March a more tragic character. But either way it goes I'm happy with it I also like that Snyder is taking these villains and making them Bruce Wayne villains insead of Batman villains. The Court of Owls seem to have it out for the Waynes and here now we have Lincoln March, and the same resently with Mr. Freeze. All villians of Bruce Wayne.

Avatar image for rorschach2814
Rorschach2814

32

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Rorschach2814

Im gunna say it........Instant classic. I'm sure at the end of the series this story with fall in the top 10 if not 5 best batman series ever written. Its not just the story though, the art and the coloring are unlike anything ive ever seen in a batman book and i hope this creative teem can stay on this book for as long as possible. they have just done an amazing job. Already saving my money the Absolute edition, cause you know its gunna have the honor of becoming glorified in the giant hard cover! Cant wait.

Avatar image for madrooster81
MadRooster81

186

Forum Posts

8

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By MadRooster81

I'm interested in seeing where this goes. I mean as of now we don't know if this is indeed Bruces brother. All we got right now is that this guy claims to be Thomas Wayne Jr., this doesn't make him that. I think there are more surprises in the next couple of issues.

Avatar image for kinglypack
Kinglypack

7

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By Kinglypack

Loved it... was a little puzzled abut #10 but liked it... glad Snyder is not just pulling the mythos around by its nose like so many other Batman writers.

Avatar image for sethysquare
sethysquare

3965

Forum Posts

150

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

Edited By sethysquare

One of the best Batman stories I've read.