Either you didn't see my post on time or you didn't think you messed up. Well, time to get to work.
@zariusii said:
Ha, not phased by it at all. Sorry to disappoint you @saintwildcard.
JL Action isn't really as big a deal as you lot claim, I've checked in on a few episodes, and there's way more consequential drama and interesting character dynamics and motivations packed into seven minutes of Steven Universe than this.
Let's talk about REAL exposure...the Zack Synder movies, for better or for worse, champion Lois and Clark. The CW's Supergirl champions Lois and Clark together also, despite Lois not appearing there as of yet, Clark is definitely with her.
You say you're not affected but the fact that you had to use BvS to make your Pro Clois argument shows a true sense of desperation. I think if they put out a movie where Superman just rapes and beats Lois for an hour, you'd still quote it as part of your defense. But like I said before, you messed up twice in your reply, this being one of them. You used BvS, but then later on said that even though it's gonna be on this show that it doens't matter cus it won't be high quality. Which you yourself even admitted BvS wasnt. See the hypocrisy? I might as well quote that one porno by the Parody Porn company where Superman and Wonder WOman bang. Atleast people leave watching that happy. (zinger)
YOu also use Supergirl which wasn't even an appearance but a passing reference. Scraping the bottom of the barrel ain't you? Plus... it's a horrible show. Not even because of that, just in general. Subjective, yes. But still, the use of this non promotion is weak sauce.
Steven Universe is Terrible, don't you even go there. That show is straight up shite.
Even if Superman Reborn in the comics is presently hinting at tragic days coming for Lois and Clark, at least that will provide interesting drama and test their bond like never before, which can make for far better reading than two overpowered gods holding hands and attempting to make out, either in the pages of a hopelessly rotten team book or in a corny series of shorts that don't really provide much substance compared to, say, Justice League Unlimited (where Diana was more infatuated with Batman, and that relationship was way more believable)
Downplaying the action and drama the relationship can bring doesn't make your point right or prove that nothing can be done. That's just you lacking imagination. I just had a discussion with someone about why it could work, and it opened his eyes. He even likes the Clois relationship. This isn't to say that everyone should love it, or that you can't like CLois more, but you seem to talk as if though it's impossible to like it and that anyone who does is just some idiot. you do this more later on, which is the second time you messed up in your reply. As for the JLU BM/WW relationship, that was just done to make Batman look more badass, just like how Bruce TImm made Barabara bang Bruce. What makes it even worse is not only did that relationship go nowhere on that show but Timm even said that Bruce will end up alone. This dance of Bruce rejecting women cus he has to keep being Batman has been played out and done with everyone, you don't do that with the female icon though. If you wanna have them date, then that's find. But Timm never did and says it wouldn't happen anyway. I didn't even like that when they did it with SM and WW in Pre 52. Where she wanted Clark but he was married, that shit just shouldn't fly. Maybe with her own characters but if the relationship only goes one way with the other big two, it just feels like a power move.
I still take great comfort in the stark reality mainline comics Diana already wrote off her relationship with Clark as nothing but a fling. I see the two of them in JL Action with the same two pairs of eyes that I see their relationship in the comics as, both when it briefly was highlighted in the 80s and when it came back in N52...a fling. Something they'll grow out of. If the show does want to flesh out itself, they'll no doubt add a Lois or Steve to spice things up as DC delve further into their Rebirth era and the cartoon may have to adjust to reflect that.
*sigh* again with your lack of imagination. Anyway, the show itself is just meant to be fun and appealing to kids. Which by the way, it is getting good reviews from everywhere I see but I guess when it doesn't suit your narrative the reviews don't matter. If it's about Rebirth, all the reviews and whoever you see praising it automatically matters. But now, with this show just cus it's gonna go for a more kid friendly/action packed/comedic take it's no better than TTGO.... despite the fact that you haven't seen it.
I'm not even going to go as far as to say that they might not break up, but it sure as hell won't be to bring in Rebirth. That shit is to convoluted to do not to mention the sceneario with Superman in that book is in no way what's gonna happen with this Superman. All you're saying is that you want them to bring back the CLois relationship... which again goes against your "not caring" statement.
S/WW may live (and really, there's no reason it shouldn't), but really, when faced with decades upon decades of Lois and Clark's story, the fact Lois and Clark have a son and legacy while the sort of legacy Clark and Diana can settle for is a fling in mainline canon (now mercifully ended), a fling in an throwaway cartoon and a bratty daughter in Frank Miller's universe...it's still very much in the nursery compared to all of that history. That history will inform the next generation as they get older, and most will probably turn to the one pairing history has shown is a consistent winner.
Screw up number dos. But also kinda Three, you bring up Frank Millers failure of a sequel with TDKRSB as proof of a child of SM/WW child not working. Which isn't even a SM/WW book and the book just takes shits on Superman, truly shocking how their child doesn't work in that huh? The true depiction if I were to argue for this, would be Hyperman from Kingdom Come. Plus I Squall actually recommended one series that had their children in it that was a partial sequel to KC.
But back to screw up Number Dos. You say that people will grow out of it, and what not.... why hasn't that happened already? With like everyone who likes the SM/WW relationship? Like Me? Why is it that Hot Topic still pumps out merch? Why was it a big deal in the three JL New 52 films? Why is DC putting in deleted SM/WW issues in the Final Days trades?
And please, try not to reply with something as obviously biased and short sighted as "well they're idiots". With all the history and the very few moments of exposure the SM/WW relationship has had, it should be a cinch... and yet it hasn't happened.
People aren't blind sheeps if they don't align with your way of thinking. Valid arguments by adults can be made for the SM/WW relationship, and those kids could come to learn them as well. I'm not saying all kids will love the SM/WW relationship or even care, but some will. And to just write them off as sheep or whatever, just shows how petty your are. I'm not arguing that this show is a game changer or that it'll make the SM?WW relationship overtake the CLois one, just saying that this will garner attention to the ship and make some new fans. And to just bad mouth the kids or deny that it'll happen is just being blind. I'm not being blind when it comes to Rebirth Superman and it's sales, why can't you not be blind or dismissive to kids?
I wish you well with your little "victory", but let's face it, there hasn't been a decent or even memorable DC cartoon since Young Justice ended, so I'm not worried. All the better is that YJ is coming back and we don't have to necessarily settle for empty calories like this and Teen Titans Go for much longer.
That's all you really have with this. Empty calories.
Heh, the hypocrisy is priceless. All this effort even though you say you don't care. So many contradictions and lack of imagination. Generalizations galore. Try harder next time
Log in to comment