Can the Hulk survive in space?

  • 51 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for power_nexus
#1 Posted by Power NeXus (10283 posts) - - Show Bio

Would he be killed if someone were to throw him into space?
Avatar image for thejuggernautpunch
#2 Posted by TheJuggernautpunch (6151 posts) - - Show Bio

I think yes . I remember someone posted a video on youtube with scans showing that Hulk can suffocate in space . He can hold his breath , but not for long . Plus Hulk needs to rest , eat and drink .

Avatar image for princeimc
#3 Posted by PrinceIMC (5506 posts) - - Show Bio

He should but they'd probably come up with some BS reason for him to survive. The Gamma radiation keeps his body from freezing and he goes into hibernation or something silly like that.

Avatar image for illituracy
#4 Posted by iLLituracy (13545 posts) - - Show Bio

No Caption Provided
It's in the same issue where his breathing apparatus is broken, he's eventually overcome by the weapon he was shot in space to fight and taken aboard it's satellite.
 
An issue or two later, Bruce transforms into Hulk to fight the weapon inside the satellite. The fight spills out into space, mind you, he no longer has his breathing apparatus and ends on the Moon. 
 
So, yes, Hulk can survive in space. How long? I don't know if there's a determined amount of time, but it seems he doesn't need to breathe in space, anymore. Didn't he also beat the Skrull Black Bolt on the moon, as well?
Avatar image for strongestonethereis
#5 Posted by StrongestOneThereIs (7064 posts) - - Show Bio

He survived in space during WWHulk, he is shown outside the ship smashing asteroids.

Avatar image for strongestonethereis
#6 Posted by StrongestOneThereIs (7064 posts) - - Show Bio
@iLLituracy said:
"
No Caption Provided
It's in the same issue where his breathing apparatus is broken, he's eventually overcome by the weapon he was shot in space to fight and taken aboard it's satellite.  An issue or two later, Bruce transforms into Hulk to fight the weapon inside the satellite. The fight spills out into space, mind you, he no longer has his breathing apparatus and ends on the Moon.   So, yes, Hulk can survive in space. How long? I don't know if there's a determined amount of time, but it seems he doesn't need to breathe in space, anymore. Didn't he also beat the Skrull Black Bolt on the moon, as well? "
All true!
And he also stood outside his ship when heading to Earth before the WWHulk story started.
Avatar image for danhimself
#7 Posted by danhimself (21434 posts) - - Show Bio

I doubt that it applies to 616 Hulk but I remember Ultimate Tony Stark saying that Ultimate Hulk basically mutates whatever he needs to survive

Avatar image for king_hercules
#8 Edited by King Hercules (1253 posts) - - Show Bio
@danhimself said:

" I doubt that it applies to 616 Hulk but I remember Ultimate Tony Stark saying that Ultimate Hulk basically mutates whatever he needs to survive "

The Hulk sent into space to fight the Android was 616 Hulk
Avatar image for the_wind_stalker
#9 Posted by The Wind-Stalker (67 posts) - - Show Bio

of course he would die does any1 remember on the hulk movie they made remember he was on the jet and he went up into the clouds he started banging his head on the pilot window cause he going to high............. the hulk couldnt breathe 

Avatar image for king_hercules
#10 Posted by King Hercules (1253 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Wind-Stalker said:
"of course he would die does any1 remember on the hulk movie they made remember he was on the jet and he went up into the clouds he started banging his head on the pilot window cause he going to high............. the hulk couldnt breathe  "

That was a movie version of the character. Not the 616 version.
Avatar image for speedlgt
#11 Posted by speedlgt (2138 posts) - - Show Bio

he should NOT
Avatar image for jay00
#12 Edited by Jay00 (2 posts) - - Show Bio

In The Amazing Spider-Man issue #328, spidey thought Hulk was gonna hurt some kids so he knocked him into orbit...
 
At the time, the change was dependent on the sun
He said the cold didn't bother him
And he could hold his breath along time.
If he turns into Banner he's dead...
 
SPOILER:  spidey ends up rescuing him with the beyonders temp powers..
 
hey....i look like Bennett.... my horned rim glasses...

Avatar image for illituracy
#13 Posted by iLLituracy (13545 posts) - - Show Bio

I remember answering this question...up there somewhere. :[
 
@Jay00 said:

" In The Amazing Spider-Man issue #328, spidey thought Hulk was gonna hurt some kids so he knocked him into orbit...  At the time, the change was dependent on the sun He said the cold didn't bother him And he could hold his breath along time. If he turns into Banner he's dead...  SPOILER:  spidey ends up rescuing him with the beyonders temp powers..  hey....i look like Bennett.... my horned rim glasses... "
This happens way before he adapted to outer space's conditions and he developed the ability to be out there unaided for prolonged amount of times. This was an issue that tied into the Acts of Vengeance.
 
Also, this was Grey Hulk. He also didn't have the Beyonder's power, he had the Enigma Force and was temporarily Captain Universe.
Avatar image for hulksmash134
#14 Posted by hulksmash134 (205 posts) - - Show Bio

hulk can breathe in space

Avatar image for captainhulk
#15 Posted by CaptainHulk (2 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes, he is able to breathe due to his body developing a gland which creates an oxygenated perfluorocarbon emulsion which fills his lungs and equalizes the pressure. He is therefore able to breathe in space and underwater.

Avatar image for crypto_jones
#16 Edited by Crypto_Jones (33 posts) - - Show Bio

@captainhulk said:

Yes, he is able to breathe due to his body developing a gland which creates an oxygenated perfluorocarbon emulsion which fills his lungs and equalizes the pressure. He is therefore able to breathe in space and underwater.

I remember seeing that. Although it would only provide for fluid breathing. If there is no input of gas or fluid of any kind, it's a pretty useless ability. Still, can anyone provide a scan? The only way I can see hulk surviving long term in space is if he somehow adapts to absorb rays through his skin (like superman). If I was a writer looking for a twist it's what I'd do. Then again, it would provide limited energy and he'd have to go in a state of stasis.

That being said, there are a couple of ways Hulk could survive in space, and it's my understanding that the whole "If hulk turns back to banner, he dies" point is moot, as the minds of Banner AND Hulk would not let that happen. Unconsciously, the entity that they form together will remain in the form that will allow it to survive (In "The End", when Banner dies, Hulk takes over, for exemple).

Avatar image for joygirl
#17 Edited by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

And this right here is why Hulk is silly.

Avatar image for extremis
#18 Posted by Extremis (3742 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl: whys that? There are plenty of other characters who can survive in space. By that logic we should call all fictional superheroes "silly"as none of them make any real sense to begin with.

Avatar image for joygirl
#20 Posted by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: *dies* @extremis: Characters that can survive in space can generally survive in space since their conception. They don't just magically develop a new power that they never had, for no reason but the sake of being more powerful. When you hand a character anything they want free of charge they cease to be challenged. Hulk used to have limits -- he was so, he couldn't fly, he wasn't spaceworthy, he wasn't that smart, you could manipulate the gamma energy in him, etc. Now slowly but surely everything that's limited him has been circumvented or outright removed, discounting the fact that his strength cap has increased exponentially from what it was 50 years ago.

Avatar image for joygirl
#21 Edited by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

*slow, not so

Avatar image for wolverine008
#22 Posted by Wolverine008 (50897 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl said:

@theacidskull: *dies* @extremis: Characters that can survive in space can generally survive in space since their conception. They don't just magically develop a new power that they never had, for no reason but the sake of being more powerful. When you hand a character anything they want free of charge they cease to be challenged. Hulk used to have limits -- he was so, he couldn't fly, he wasn't spaceworthy, he wasn't that smart, you could manipulate the gamma energy in him, etc. Now slowly but surely everything that's limited him has been circumvented or outright removed, discounting the fact that his strength cap has increased exponentially from what it was 50 years ago.

Aren't increases in power kind of standard among comic characters? If I really sat down and named all the popular and overall comic characters that have had their power increased over the years, I'd be able to right a book. I'm not really a major Hulk fan but I don't see how him becoming more powerful takes away from the main aspect of him (The psychological warfare between him and Bruce Banner.)

Avatar image for joygirl
#23 Posted by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

@wolverine08: There's a big difference between increasing in power/power creeping and instantly developing whole new powers overnight (such as the ability to breathe in space, or his current super speed). Everyone gets more powerful but unless their power specifically ties into the acquisition of new powers (as Hulk's does not) they usually don't magically sprout whole new abilities.

Avatar image for kidchipotle
#24 Posted by kidchipotle (15524 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah, why not?

Avatar image for crypto_jones
#25 Edited by Crypto_Jones (33 posts) - - Show Bio

@wolverine08 said:

@joygirl said:

@theacidskull: *dies* @extremis: Characters that can survive in space can generally survive in space since their conception. They don't just magically develop a new power that they never had, for no reason but the sake of being more powerful. When you hand a character anything they want free of charge they cease to be challenged. Hulk used to have limits -- he was so, he couldn't fly, he wasn't spaceworthy, he wasn't that smart, you could manipulate the gamma energy in him, etc. Now slowly but surely everything that's limited him has been circumvented or outright removed, discounting the fact that his strength cap has increased exponentially from what it was 50 years ago.

Aren't increases in power kind of standard among comic characters? If I really sat down and named all the popular and overall comic characters that have had their power increased over the years, I'd be able to right a book. I'm not really a major Hulk fan but I don't see how him becoming more powerful takes away from the main aspect of him (The psychological warfare between him and Bruce Banner.)

EVERY SINGLE character's transition from the golden age to the silver age. I mean golden age Superman would have a fair fight with Luke Cage. It's normal that Hulk would evolve in such a way.

Avatar image for wolverine008
#26 Posted by Wolverine008 (50897 posts) - - Show Bio

@wolverine08 said:

@joygirl said:

@theacidskull: *dies* @extremis: Characters that can survive in space can generally survive in space since their conception. They don't just magically develop a new power that they never had, for no reason but the sake of being more powerful. When you hand a character anything they want free of charge they cease to be challenged. Hulk used to have limits -- he was so, he couldn't fly, he wasn't spaceworthy, he wasn't that smart, you could manipulate the gamma energy in him, etc. Now slowly but surely everything that's limited him has been circumvented or outright removed, discounting the fact that his strength cap has increased exponentially from what it was 50 years ago.

Aren't increases in power kind of standard among comic characters? If I really sat down and named all the popular and overall comic characters that have had their power increased over the years, I'd be able to right a book. I'm not really a major Hulk fan but I don't see how him becoming more powerful takes away from the main aspect of him (The psychological warfare between him and Bruce Banner.)

EVERY SINGLE character's transition from the golden age to the silver age. I mean golden age Superman would have a fair fight with Luke Cage. It's normal that Hulk would evolve in such a way.

Agreed. Major power increases are just the norm in comics now.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#28 Posted by joshmightbe (27428 posts) - - Show Bio

@hulksmash134: technically nothing can breath in space. Theres no air

Avatar image for joygirl
#29 Edited by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: Doomsday's power is adaptation/evolution. It's his only power. But whatever, I'm not gonna gain any traction here so I may as well drop it.

Avatar image for joygirl
#31 Posted by Joygirl (21033 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: Without explanation? Absolutely. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind if characters increase in power. I just get peeved when it happens for no reason. If Hulk had always had an ability to adapt and was able to adapt to space upon his first visit, I'd be fine. But once upon a time he used to have to breathe which makes the mutation utterly random, and therefore ridiculous.

Avatar image for risingbean
#32 Posted by RisingBean (9314 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl: If it makes you feel any better, Hulk has been space worthy since at least 83'

Avatar image for extremis
#34 Posted by Extremis (3742 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl: as others have said, we'd expect to see differences in characters 50 years later. Nearly every popular character has new abilities/traits/personalities than they did in the golden or silver age.

The essence of the character itself is still completely intact, which is what is really important. But considering the Hulk's physiology it's not like this alteration just fell out of the sky.

Bruce Wayne suddenly being able to survive in a space vacuum would raise alarms as he has a human body. But it's not so alarming with Hulk. Hulk has always had adaptive regenerative qualities with his physiology so this isn't even a stretch of the imagination.

Avatar image for mikex20
#35 Posted by mikex20 (3146 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk can survive in space for a time, but not permanently like the Surfer.

Avatar image for mikex20
#37 Posted by mikex20 (3146 posts) - - Show Bio

@mikex20 said:

Hulk can survive in space for a time, but not permanently like the Surfer.

he can. he adapts.

His adaption allows him to survive for a long period of time, finding ways to consume his oxygen at an extremely low rate. But he eventually needs to replenish it.

Avatar image for _atomikill_
#39 Edited by _Atomikill_ (4861 posts) - - Show Bio

I think yes . I remember someone posted a video on youtube with scans showing that Hulk can suffocate in space . He can hold his breath , but not for long . Plus Hulk needs to rest , eat and drink .

Hulk can hold his breath for hours, but yeah, he will die eventually.

Avatar image for mikex20
#40 Edited by mikex20 (3146 posts) - - Show Bio

@mikex20 said:

@theacidskull said:

@mikex20 said:

Hulk can survive in space for a time, but not permanently like the Surfer.

he can. he adapts.

His adaption allows him to survive for a long period of time, finding ways to consume his oxygen at an extremely low rate. But he eventually needs to replenish it.

proof of this.

He just recently spoke freely in hickmans avengers without needing oxygen.

He will eventually go into a state of suspended animation, until he reaches a source of oxygen.

Avatar image for mikex20
#42 Posted by mikex20 (3146 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: He wouldn't wear an oxygen mask if he didn't need it.

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for mikex20
#44 Posted by mikex20 (3146 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: He takes it off because he can survive for awhile without it, but not forever.

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
#46 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (45406 posts) - - Show Bio

Why are pepole quoting 3 year old posts?

Avatar image for crypto_jones
#47 Edited by Crypto_Jones (33 posts) - - Show Bio

@mikex20 said:

@theacidskull: He wouldn't wear an oxygen mask if he didn't need it.

No Caption Provided

Do I have to point out that the argument is countered in the same scan you just posted? Even if he loses the mask, he will adapt to the zero-oxygen environment. Shield simply isn't taking any chances.

Also let's keep in mind: the fight between him and Black Bolt took place on the blue area of the moon, which has an atmosphere.

Avatar image for tpodvorec
#48 Edited by tpodvorec (1 posts) - - Show Bio

@theacidskull: first: so if the orange guy (whose name I don't want to misspell) can create an entire corps using his ring why can't Atrocitus make a few energy construct copies of himself.

Second: Being that it is a vacuum nobody can breath in space unless they have some sort of atmosphere containing the gases they need in order to breath. So the Hulk's not breathing (since there's nothing for him to breath) he starts out holding his breath then begins suffocating being kept alive by his near invulnerability and his healing factor healing any damage done to him by lack of oxygen. So as you can imagine when he has breathable air he breaths because constantly suffocating and never dying sucks about as badly as dying from it (depending on your opinion of spending long periods of time suffocating is).

Avatar image for hulk465
#49 Edited by hulk465 (106 posts) - - Show Bio

In Avengers the ultimate guide it says about Hulk:" Able to adapt in ANY environment, underwater or airless space INDEFINITELY"

In incredible Hulk-111 (which came out in 1969 and is older than a lot folks making comments here) Hulk is shown right on the cover in deep space. In the issue it shows Hulk destroying a spaceship all without air in deep space and the spaceship crash lands on an alien planet.

So yeah, Hulk has been surviving in space in the comics LONG before most of you guys making comments were even born.

As for the 1st Hulk movie, Hulk needed time to adapt but was not needed cause he fell back to earth. So that power could NOT be shown. Gen. Ross assumed that Hulk might get knocked out due to lack of air and cold temp.

Just because a comic fan does not believe it to be true, does NOT make it true.......I go by the Authority(Marvel) and NOT the majority of the folks here who make careless comments about stuff they know nothing about..

Avatar image for renovatio74
#50 Edited by Renovatio74 (5 posts) - - Show Bio

There is no way for hulk to adapt to things that aren't earthkind. hulk was birthed on a planet with air and water hence his makeup coming from a human he can adapt to water. hulk was not birthed in a place with no air so how can his physiology (being partly human with no magic) survive in space. It makes no sense.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.