@arcus1: Check out my edited list. Honestly my appraisal of Ward's h2h went down a bit on my AoS rewatch, maybe that's why I think Nat's a bit more skilled now. I said this on Discord and I can't put any better than I already did: "He's definitely skilled, really skilled. But I think he's supposed to be a brilliant soldier & operative more than he is supposed to be a pure martial arts prodigy."
That being said, I think he beats Nat by feats, his overall capability as a fighter is too good by feats tbh.
My appraisal of Davos and the supersoldiers also went down tbh.
...did you just rewatch AoS since making that initial list?
And yeah, I don't think he was intended to be a pure martial artist the way other high tiers are. No disrespect to him (martial arts are not the only valuable combat skill)
By feats, it'd be reasonable to argue for him beating Nat. He'd have to exploit his physical advantage like he did against May (though I think Nat's supposed to be more physical than May-she's younger and not as small
Davos is kinda difficult, imo, cause he relies so much on scaling from Danny, and even then his status compared to Danny is kinda contextual (ie how much does Danny hold back against him, even maybe without meaning to?). Between that and his relative lack of feats, I'm fine with him being lower
I wouldn't have Daisy that far above the supersoldiers, especially if you're arguing that she's low level superhuman (not sure what your current stance is on that issue). From a story perspective, I don't think it would make any sense for her to be multiple tiers above the likes of Cap and Panther, both of whom have been training since before she learned to throw a punch, have better statements regarding their skill levels (statements about being "the best soldiers in the world-in reference to Cap's upgraded h2h skills in Winter Soldier, I believe" or "trained to the highest levels of fighting"-not sufficient in isolation, but helpful, and I'm looking for the exact interviews I'm thinking of for context), and feats against other skilled fighters (mainly Bucky, but also each other). Based on feats, I'm comfortable saying Daisy's comparable with them, but I have a hard time seeing them as being much lower. Plus, if we say Daisy's superhuman, that takes away from her skill, since the majority of her most impressive skill showings are her fights against superhumans (fighting superhumans is less impressive if you're also a superhuman)
Log in to comment