7/10
Positives- Jean was very quick in showcasing leadership skills and the ability to lead a title and set the tone for a series. Cassandra Nova was a great antagonist and we got a flesh out of her strengths weakness and most importantly how she deals with loses and setbacks, arguably she set out with a plan and escalated the stakes to a point that i don't think any other X-team couldve convincingly overcome. The coloring fo the book was great and global travel was helped greatly by the different feels of the different locations.
I love that throughout this series we see them building toward a clash of ideas and watch as both the X-Team and Nova escalate against eachother.
Negatives- Jean is emotionless. The art never expresses anything for her, and for as much as Jean and Nova's conflict is based around empathy and emotion, Jean seems to talk about feelings perform acts of empathy alot more then she showcases them. A woman blows up in front of her she's not phased, a fellow X-Man and a woman she considers her daughter are kidnapped and mindcontrolled and she doesnt seem phased personally. Hell it could even be argued that she's actually annoyed by everyone being negative and is only out to fix the world and stop Nova because it's messing up her ressurection high.
The cast is a problem. The older X-Men are more set pieces and familiar faces who don't do anything except get a nice line an issue and get our attention on the covers. The newer X-Men are really forced, with alot of what they do coming off as justification for them being there then anything else. Gentle isn't a character here, he's a plot piece for Jean to show empathy and for Trinary to have a love interest. Trinary is a plot device whose only purpose on any level is based around Nova being a tech villain. Gabby..... smh. Gabby is great in small doses. Here, she's annoying as hell as she has answers and fake-sage like wisdom for everyone. The scene where she gives Jean the idea of how to attack Nova and the final defeat of Nova are so silly they hurt since it dumbs down others to make her useful.
Overall- It's fun. If it had been a 24 issue series with the same plot I could've seen these problems being crippling. But even still the plotting was good and every issue improves upon the last. For what seems like a lot of negatives, the book it's self is pretty solid without a single bad issue and in retrospect as Jean's return is filled with more personal characterization the lack of emoting in this series becomes less of a problem. And I can't really say that if the book continued after this story it wouldn't have fleshed out the background characters more.
But in the end the series ended with me wanting more X-Men: Red
Log in to comment