@ashetdust: Lol your missing out. His 90s solo is entirely about him developing his TP & TK, his relationships with Scott and Jean eventually culminating in him embracing the Askani Religion and becoming the Savior persona with God-Like TP & TK.

His adventures during the Onslaught and Bastian arcs are especially good because it's kinda just about him doing X-Men and investigating who they are and their plans.

X-Force Cable & Cable post Hope is very much the "Grrrr.....bullets" guy, but Cable in his solo and X-men days was great for just being a mutant.

X-Factor

While I liked some ideas from that X-Factor, it was more of the same old shit. I don't think I ever read that X-Force title so, I can't say.

Just to butt in here, yeah, I agree that Cable is one of the worst characters. Everything about him is basically an early Jim Lee/Liefeld 90s stereotype. And he's extremely inconsistent as well, sometimes he's a Clint Eastwood type, other times a Messiah, but, most of the time he's less than interesting. The Askani stuff is super cliched as well, and the whole, "I used to use my super potent TK to keep my body from falling apart" is one of the most laughably bad retcons for a character ever.

@indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

All-New X-Factor wins 4-2

• The following (and last) five matches will have 3 options, (cuz logistic reasons)
• Choose one option

Round 1 - Match 20

Generation Hope (Gillen)

vs

X-Men Legacy vol 2 (Spurrier)

vs

Generation X (Strain)

Legions Legacy was the best by a small margin over Hopes.

Gen X had potential that was squandered by issue 2

Legacy vol 2

Legacy. But Hope was decent too.

Legacy

X-Men Legacy

@indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

Legacy wins 5-0-0

Round 1 - Match 21

All-New Wolverine (Taylor)

vs

Jean Grey (Hopeless)

vs

Cyclops (Rucka/Layman)

Cyclops.

Payne you're too fast. I missed two votings already 😕

All New Wolverine.

I vote death

@adamtrmm: Shit, sorry xd

I´ll take it into account.

Yikes! Well, Cyclops was written by Greg Rucka so it must have had some good moments but i didn't read it so I guess I'll have to abstain.

All New Wolverine

@indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

All-New Wolverine wins 2-1

Round 1 - Match 22

Iceman (Grace)

vs

Old Man Logan (Lemire/Brisson)

vs

Exiles (Ahmed)

Dear f$%king lord....

Um...Old Man Logan?

Iceman was freaking trash. That second run was arguably the worst solo in X-Men history.

The Exiles was just kinda a let down because it was less alternate X-Men and more just alternate everything. Things were just weird to be weird and it didnt recapture the magic.

Old man Logan at least had some interesting stuff.

Old Man Logan easily, I couldn't even get past the first arc of the other two.

Oddly enough, I thought the second run of Grace’s iceman was the better of the two.

But of these titles? OML.

@ashetdust: Lol Ashe you wanna fight? I feel like you wanna fight.

Lol seriously though I thought the Emma arc was ok if a bit boring but they seemed to have some potential as were the interactions with Kitty....It's the Sinister plot and the Ice Gandalf arcs that ruined what would've still been a forgettable run for me.

Old Man Logan by far. Especially the Jeff Lemire run.

Old Man Logan

I did ask in another thread already, but I'm very impatient (so are my colleagues), and I'm just needing some answers, all concerning the X-Men and the Phoenix Force, and a wild RP prj. Who can help me? 😊

Jesus Christ, this last decade... Exiles, I guess.

@indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

OML wins 5-1-0

Round 1 - Match 23

X-23 vol 3 (Marjorie Liu)

vs

X-23 vol 4 (Mariko Tamaki)

vs

Age of Apocalypse (Lapham)

As much as I dislike what it did to her character, I have to admit Liu's run is the best one here.

Age of Apocalype I just didn't get into because it felt like homework....had to go back and remember who everyone was, then go back and read the early 2000's run....all for a universe I wasn't very excited for to begin with.

Tamaki's run was just an ok run that by comparison to others offers little other then being better then Taylors turned out to be, fun if you like X-23 alot....but other then attaching her more to the X-Men (which I liked) kinda fell flat with the revisit of the clones plot from Taylors run

x-23 vol 3

gabby is still ugh gabby

@koays stabby gabby LOL

rip honeybager

now its "Scout" lmao ........@ashetdust great now im starting to like "stabby gabby" as gabby's new codename hahahahahahaha ha ha

Liu's X-23.

X-23.

@hopesummersforthefuture: @indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

Liu´s X-23 wins 4-0-0

Round 1 - Match 24 (Last of round)

(Had to add one more title cuz dumb me forgot).

.

.

Daken: Dark Wolverine (Way/Liu/Williams)

vs

Gambit vol 5 (Asmus)

vs

Cable vol 3 (Brisson)

vs

Mr. and Mrs. X (Thompson)

Prob Gambit....never read Dakken though

Mrs. and Mr. X

That Gambit run had some sweet covers....

Mr and Mrs X.

Daken

me too mrs and mr x...........but gambit was a close 1st too, i wanted to say both haha lol

Daken.

@hopesummersforthefuture: Right? I know some people (who must be mentally ill) don’t like them together. But for me Rogue and Gambit are one of the big three couples in Marvel. The others being Spidey with MJ and Reed with Sue.

Yes I still like Jott, I just like the other couples better! LoL

@hopesummersforthefuture: @indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

Mr and Mrs X wins 3-2-0

Thanks for voting , Round 1 is over.

But before continuing with Round 2, I need some of your opinions on two participants, both won their matches:

X-Men Legacy (2008-2012)

24 issues were pre 2010 = about 35% of the run.

44 issues were in 2010s = about 64% of the run.

X-Factor (2005-2013)

51 issues were pre 2010 = about 44% of the run

63 issues were in 2010s = about 55% of the run.

-

Either way, the contest only takes into account the issues that were part of the 2010s decade, but it called my attention and I wanted to see if you had suggestions regarding this. Maybe some of you could think you cannot judge the run if it´s not the whole thing, etc.

-

So with this info, treating either case separately, do you guys think they should continue

or we should stick only with runs that started in the 2010s

Another case is New Mutants, but that has only 8 issues pre 2010, the other 42 are 2010s. So I think it has no "problem".

But with these two, what are your thoughts?

Should I replace one of them? Both? Or should both continue?

If some of you could give opinoins, I would apreciate it.

X-Men Legacy you can kinda separate mentally into Xavier & Rogue runs, with Rogue being most of the 10s

X-Factor is so interwoven idk what to even say about it except Polaris and Havok eventually join in the 10s....but the story is still to tight.

I think you should keep them in the contest.

Keeping them in the contest seems fair. While both books cannot be really separated into two parts as a whole, we can at least judge those books by the story arcs that came after the 2010s.

Just keep them.

@koays: hi

lol had to re-sign in

XD XD XP

@hopesummersforthefuture: @indomitableregal: @god_spawn: @wolviesnikt: @cattlebattle: @morpheus_: @jota23: @koays: @adamtrmm: @invain: @theincrediblesuperhulk8642: @waitomegastorm: @thor_parker82: @ashetdust: @vishop_: @tdk_1997: @time1:

Round 2 - Match 1

X-Men: Red (Taylor) vs X-Men: Blue (Bunn)

X-Men Red

Bunn I guess...

Red