john_martone's X-Men: Misfits #1 - Vol. 1 review

    Avatar image for john_martone
    • Score:
    • john_martone wrote this review on .
    • 4 out of 4 Comic Vine users found it helpful.

    Manga X-men stands up without being too gimmicky



    No Caption Provided

    Vital Stats

    Title: X-Men: Misfits Volume #1
    Created by: Raina Telgemeier, David Roman, Anzu
    Published by: Del Rey Manga
    Release Date: August 11, 2009 
     

    The Review (video)

      

      

    The Plot:

     
    No Caption Provided

    Kitty Pryde is a girl who has a problem fitting in. One could even say she's out of touch with those around her. This is one part because of her tender age, and another because her mutant power makes her intangible. She excitedly transfers from her local high school to the prestigious Xaviers School for the Gifted, but finds out her problems are only starting. See, back home she was a freak for being a "Mutant," but at Xavier's... she's the only girl.
     

    The Summary

     
    Loved it, but then again slap a pretty looking cast of a X-child misfits and I would be game.
     
    The art is comfortable to any shojo fan, or at least passable enough to get to the real meat of X-Men Misfits... Hot Kitty Pryde action. She's pretty stock in terms of her foibles and awkward belief that she's ugly and unlovable, but that doesn't maker her any less enjoyable. I actually really enjoyed Kitty's awkwardness from her powers, her fear of falling through objects (she wears helmets and other safety gear.)
     
    Her shy antics do get a little trying, as does the Hellfire Club's motivation for wanting her (She's the only girl, and thus coveted,) but all and I enjoyed reading through it. X-men classic Magneto gets a good amount of screen time, performing his role as Xavier's greatest and worst ally, leading the elitist Hellfire Club in their Mutant supremest beliefs.
     
    No Caption Provided
    The Volume puts the romantic conflict between Ice-man and Pyro for Kitty's love, yet Iceman is almost non-present for the majority of the volume, and I have a feeling that pyro won't be as essential next time around. Oh well, "Cool vs. Hot" probably sounded a lot better than placing tanuki Beast in the front.
     
    Recommended for the bored X-Fan or anyone looking for a solid-trashy Original English language Shojo.

    Other reviews for X-Men: Misfits #1 - Vol. 1

      Yay X-Men Shojo !!! 0

      When I first heard that a manga reimagining of the X-Men and Wolverine were coming out I was very excited and so far I am very happy with the final product. X-Men: Misfits was a great take on the classic X-Men concept and characters. I enjoyed the writing and art a great deal but I wasn't a fan of the new version of Colossus or Beast. Colossus looked more like a fat old fashioned tin man with a bad mustache and Beast looked like a big fat bear/badger :( The focus on Kitty Pryde was interesting a...

      5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.