What happens if the new Thor turns out to be awesome? Would you respect the people who boycott it now? Look at Superior Spiderman, many people were boycotting it (because the way Peter died sucked and people don't like change) and it turned out be a financial and critical success. Heck, after SS finished people begged Dan Slott for more Superior Spiderman. Those who are boycotting this are overreacting.

Nah, I'm good.

lol hahah

sad but funnny

@joshmightbe:

"Thor has been used as a title before, like when Red Norvel became Thor, or when Beta Ray Bill took over as Thor for a bit or when Eric Masterson was Thor".

Yes but in different scenarios, calling her Thor is the problem for me! Why doesn't she go by her identity like B R Bill, he was worthy but never call himself Thor.

Masterson was mortally wounded by Mongoose, and is given Thor's form and powers after the original is sealed in Eric's mind, by Odin, to save Eric's life.

"Whosoever holds this hammer, if he/she be worthy, shall possess the power of Thor." Power # Identity

@knightsofdarkness2: It's not a question of being good or not good, it's how marvel butch Thor past in marvel comics, let's not even talk of his mythology and the concept of Valhalla that defines Thor and all the Aesir, where was that in Original sin 7 when he became unworthy?

@4thor: You realize tho that Thor Odinson will still be in the book, in fact early reviews are indicating that he's still a major part of the story so there is a possibility that she won't actually go by the name but if she does it won't be the first time. For instance Beta Ray Bill did in fact go by the name Beta Ray Thor briefly and Red Norvell used the name with Odin's blessing and regardless of circumstance Eric Masterson was a completely different person from the Actual Thor while he was using his name. In fact Masterson more proves my point than takes away from as it given the fact that he was only using Thor's name because he had his powers.

@joshmightbe: Yes i do realize that, i already said multiple times that i will read it no matter what! but understand the arguments from who will not!

But your arguments don't fit the mantle profile, in Masterson case the Real Thor was sealed his mind, and now the real Thor is simply unworthy of mjolnir how we will call him now THOR i think, it's his birth name! This is not like Bucky become Captain America and Steve Rogers be only Steve Rogers after that, Thor if alive always will be Thor don't you think? Why also call Thor to other character?

@4thor: My argument is simply that others have used his name before which they have.

@joshmightbe: If Jason Aaron does allow the real Thor to have a role in this book, it will be little more than that of a butt monkey and a punching bag. No purpose other than to make the impostor look good.

Thank you, that's exactly what I'm talking about.

@lvenger: You're most welcome. As I said before in an earlier comment I'd consider seeing Thor in any other comic if only to show support for the real Thor and to see what he'd be capable of without his hammer. Because I know that if he and his impostor ever fought Aaron would purposely weaken Thor.

This is a new scenario even the writer Jason Aaron mentioned that in a interview! I really have to read issue 1 to be more accurate about this change, but the way that Thor became unworthy in OS was a total mess.

@4thor: Its not a new scenario, comic writers always say that, Slott said that crap when he tried to pretend he invented the mind swap during superior spider-man. No writer is ever going to admit his new story is just a retread with boobs.

if you can dream it its been done before.

I could point out many things in books but I want to play nice.

just to elaborate, we do not need to claw our own eyes out to know it will be a painful and horrid experience with long lasting consequences

i'm going to buy it because i'm curious.

@lvenger: lol! Ditto!

Why. I have no problem with it. Im pretty sure it will be revealed to just be some ALT universe amongst the Countless other Alt universes inside of Marvel. Plus didn't That New or Next Avengers movie that had all the avengers kids star a Female who was Thors Daughter. Who knows. Maybe something crazy will happen and it will be revealed to be her.

Almighty sacred thread. I wish thee good luck. This thread is golden and the user who made it has infinite power forever and ever! May thy god of this thread live forever in happiness

salt

memes