ajshadowhawk's Thor: God of Thunder #12 - Once Upon a Time in Midgard review

    Avatar image for ajshadowhawk

    What an extremely humane side of Thor! THIS is comics brilliance.

    The review was originally posted on my blog here.

    To think, when I picked up the first issue of this series back in December last year, that I had considered the series to be of only passing interest. A full twelve issues later, here I am, a complete fan of Jason Aaron and the incredible spin he’s done on everybody’s favourite Thunder God. From a bit of a shaky beginning, Thor: God of Thunder has a come a long, long way, and is right now one of my favourite comics to read month after month. I love the character, I love the three-part narrative divided between Thors of the past, present and the future, and I love the whole mythic quality of the series. Plus that art, which has really, really grown on me.

    The series wrapped up its first major arc a couple week ago in #11 as the Thor trinity finally defeated Gorr the God-Butcher in a most spectacular fashion. The arc, in totality, has been one of the most fun stories I’ve ever read and it really was an incredible experience. Quite to my surprise, this past Wednesday, Marvel released the #12th issue in the series, a sort of interlude as the Thors get back to their regular lives and Jason Aaron begins his next big arc, whatever it may be. I don’t really look at solicits so I have no idea what’s gonna happen next. Except more awesomeness. That’s one thing I can always count on Jason Aaron for these days.

    Note: Some spoilers for this issue, although nothing… major.

    If there is any one concept that defines this issue it is “normality”. Jason Aaron does such a wonderful job of showing an ordinary day in the life of Thor when he is on Midgard. He meets new people, he makes their lives better, he comforts them, gives them hope, he stands by them, he shows them wonders, and so on. In short, he is a true hero in every sense of the word, because he cares about the little guy, the ordinary little guy that others ignore. Very much a Green Arrow-like mindset, going off the character’s portrayal in Justice League Unlimited (which is the only version I know other than the one in Smallville, which was a bit high-brow, and the one in Arrow, which largely deals with the bigger problems facing Starling City).

    Another thing is the emotion in the entire issue. Till now, Jason impressed me with all the characterisation and the action. Now, he impresses with introspection and emotion. One of the very first things that Thor does on his return to Midgard is to go see a prisoner facing execution, and he brings him the last fruit from a world that has been scoured and burned. The emotions in those scenes are just heart-breaking. I don’t know who Fulton is, but whoever he was before, meeting Thor has clearly changed his perspective on life. It was such a great emotional beat.

    Then there are all the little things, such as Thor making it rain in a desert/plains to help a poor farmer family, or sharing a beer with servicemen, or helping a fishing trawler through some tough times, or meditating with the Dalai Lama, and so on. Its all so… heroic on a basic level. He is looking to make a difference in the lives of these people, and receiving the joy of the effort in turn.

    And that brings me to the final section of this comic, Thor meeting Jane Foster again. Since I’ve not read any Thor comics prior to this series, outside of Matt Fraction’s The Mighty Thor Volume 1, I don’t know how things stand between Thor and Jane. Given this issue however, it appears that Jane is now seeing someone else, and that in fact she is undergoing chemo-therapy for breast cancer. That was doubly heartbreaking for the simple reason that my mother just had breast cancer surgery and has begun her chemo-treatments. Thor’s reaction mirrors my own, the horror and helplessness of it.

    And without giving her any kind of an action scene or anything, Jason Aaron makes Jane into, as Thor himself says, “You are a brave woman, Jane Foster”. What more needs to be said after that?

    That’s not all really. Because there’s much more with past-Thor as he returns to the Viking-way of life, and Jason gives us an extremely human-side of his character. The final dialogue by past-Thor is great. And future-Thor, well that one was supremely interesting because of the way it ends, and ends the issue in fact. “Thor always returns to Midgard”. Of course, there’s a bit more to that dialogue, but then that would be a big spoiler, I think

    The issue ends with one of the most breathtaking visuals in comics: a sunrise like nothing else. Which brings me to the art side of this issue. Nic Klein seems to have stepped up for a guest issue as writer while series regular Esad Ribic takes a break. While I deeply miss Esad’s pencils and Ive Svorcina’s colours, Nic seems to have done a pretty darn good job nonetheless. His Thor is a bit more Hollywood action-hero, kind of like how Dolph Lundgren would look as Thor in full get-up, and the overall colour palette of the issue is a bit heavy on shadows and black inks. But still, I enjoyed this issue’s artwork. It brings… diversity, and its of the good kind, so I don’t mind it at all. Plus, his Jane Foster is really great. And of course, Esad Ribic’s fantastic cover is just that, fanfrikkintastic.

    Overall, an excellent job by the entire team and I can’t wait for #13!!

    Rating: 9.5/10

    Other reviews for Thor: God of Thunder #12 - Once Upon a Time in Midgard

      Gentle Giant 0

      i've Been a fan of Jason Aaron's Thor Run, it's very consistent and quite frankly very good. His First arc was a great Success, easily Balancing the Dark tone, seriousness and the epic action. I'm very Glad that Jason Aaron decided to take one issue to Explore Thor's Character rather then Jumping on to the next big arc. That way we can take a break from all the threats and easily await what is to come.The Art is a Nice Change. It's Not really breathtaking or anything like that but you can see th...

      9 out of 9 found this review helpful.

      A Day in the Life 0

      Opening remarks:This was one of my favorite titles overall last year, even though the end of Godbomb was pretty anti-climactic. You can check out this and other reviews at my blog here.Story:The main thread of the story is surprisingly simple- we follow Thor as he conducts his relatively mundane godly duties. I say mundane, but there's no negative connotation attached to the word here.In the very beginning, we're privy to a flashback during which he's asked why he bothers coming to Midgard when ...

      3 out of 3 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.