omertalvendetta's The Punisher #1 - Punisher: One review

Avatar image for omertalvendetta

Great Storytelling.

Not the strongest aspect of the issue, but maybe it's the logo I'm not a big fan of.  That and the giant #1 there on the side; it just looks like crap. 
The Good: 
The ambiance and storytelling of this issue is splendid.  It's extremely well done, and I am a very big fan of how they manage to really show us a Frank Castle that is utterly mysterious.  The art was solid and it really sets the mood for great stuff.  I also liked the way that it carried several pages and how the art was chosen to tell the story in certain places.  I also dug the new character and the implications that may pose for future issues.   
The Bad: 
My only minor complaint is that the issue felt very fast.  That does happen often where art is used to carry certain panels (or full pages), but pages without dialogue often pose the small dilemma where the issue feels like it's going at Mach-V speed.  Besides that, nothing else bad really stood out. 
I find this to be an awesome issue, even if it's not a great first issue.  It does pose a lot of questions (as #1's should) but I think that's not altogether a bad thing here.  The art and the coloring were stupendous and the storytelling was fantastic, even if the pacing seemed a little fast. 


Other reviews for The Punisher #1 - Punisher: One

    Just Punisher. That's All I Really Wanted. 0

    Greg Rucka makes his big return to the Marvel Universe, bringing his very grounded and intelligent storytelling to a character it meshes perfectly with. Marco Checchetto joins him on art and really does a lot of heavy lifting as the issue is light on words yet remains heavy on story.  Frank Castle tends to be a problematic character, and I think the reason is that writers tend to overthink him as a lead character. The Punisher is probably the most driven and focused character in comics, making B...

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

    If this goes well we could get a Marvel version of Gotham Central 0

    Review for Punisher #1 by Greg MOTHER*&%@#$! Rucka.  The Story: A gang called TheExchange shoots up a wedding and two detectives are put on the case but Punisher finds them and kills a majority of them. The side story is Walter Bolt talking about a case where is partner was killed and says he killed the gang members but in reality Frank did the job.  The Good: Rucka was able to tell a great story and barely used Frank in this. He sets up who the villain will be for this arc, who will be the ...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.