cyclonus_the_warrior's Superman: Brainiac #1 - HC review

    Avatar image for cyclonus_the_warrior

    He knows him but he doesn't.

    Thirty-five years ago the planet of Krypton was attacked by a horde of Brainiac robots, and at the end of the conflict before Krypton's destruction the city of Kandor was captured. In the present, Superman responds to a situation only to encounter Brainiac. However, according to Supergirl, he's never met the real Brainiac. Superman embarks on a solo mission to battle a menace he knows, yet he doesn't know at all. -summary

    One thing I could always hand to Geoff Johns, he knows how to make superhero stories fun (loved his run on Green Lantern). While writers like Mike Millar, Grant Morrison, and Garth Ennis will take you on some really nice cerebral trips. Johns tends to keep things moderately simple and deliver a story akin to the summer blockbusters. And in the case of Superman, rarely would I find his works to be boring. Personally, I think he has Superman down to a science and stories such as Superman: Brainiac is the proof. Collecting Action Comics 866 - 870, and Superman: New Krypton Special One. Superman: Brainiac is a five issue series that pits the Man of Steel against the most powerful incarnation of Brainiac at this point. In the process, Johns also reaches deep into the past of pre-crisis, bringing back the bottled city of Kandor and the original form of Brainiac which felt all types of awesome when I first read this.

    First of all, if you're looking for something to put your brain in knots, then you're better off looking for something else. This is your above average comic,with Superman taking on an ultimate threat. The main antagonist is developed very well, since the reader will witness Brainiac destroying an entire world almost as quick as it took him to invade it. Supergirl guest stars here, and Brainiac is also developed through her due to her obvious fear of the villain. There's actually a dual character development going on here that doesn't feel like a time waster.

    The plot is very quick paced and straight to the point. There are even moments of straight up action and no dialog at all, which is rarely a bad thing. Johns also does a rather good job with the suspense and even that surprise ending. The only gripes I can probably think of would be the use of Brainiac himself. Being the super intelligent entity that he is, I was expecting more of a battle of wits, instead he was far more on the physical side. It felt awkward for him to claim that Superman couldn't out think him, when they were slugging it out the entire time.

    I have to say the artwork is near flawless. Minus the lack of detail, Gary Frank drew Superman splendid as he appears to heavily resemble Christopher Reeves. The character designs are all around great, with some nice models for Cat Grant and Supergirl. Brainiac especially looks awesome and very intimidating. John Sibal delivered with the inks and the backgrounds look very good. The inside of Brainiac's ship provides the sci-fi feel with many inhabitants from different species caged up in what appears to be over-sized, pearl shaped bottles. The action panels are nothing at all to look down on, as Superman even uses his heat vision to burn a huge scar across Brainiac's face.

    Superman: Brainiac delivers the goods for sure and that ending may have been unexpected. This story also carries over and sets the stage for the New Krypton saga, so it actually serves a purpose. For me, this began one of the more interesting Superman arcs to come around in awhile around that time. Recommended if you feel burned out by the more thought provoking stories, or if you're a fan of Superman.

    Pros: Fast paced basic superheroing story

    Cons: Small issues with writing

    Other reviews for Superman: Brainiac #1 - HC

      The Return of Kandor and Brainiac 0

      I will say I havent read a lot of Superman comics. I guess I just havent got around to reading a lot of his. From the ones I have read this is one of the better ones and was a very enjoyable and quick read. This story served to reintroduce Brainiac and the city of Kandor in pre Flashpoint continuity and it does a really good job at that. The story focuses on Brainiac trying to find Clark and Clark trying to find Brainiac. Supergirl is also in this story and she deals with what happened on Krypto...

      4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

      Poor Jon Kent. What is he, the Duncan Idaho of the Superman Universe? 0

      Picking up this volume and reading it as if it is some accessible story is somewhat misleading, since we are at once given the impression this is a new introductory story to Superman and his friends and family, yet it also contains enough self-universe-references to confuse the careful reader who has unsuspectingly checked this out from the library (combined with the notion this was apparently in the continuity of Action Comics ... if there is such a thing anymore). This story gives us a lot to ...

      1 out of 3 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.