capelesscrusader's Superman #9 - Secrets & Lies review

Avatar image for capelesscrusader

Capeless Crusader Reviews "Superman #9"

While the rest of the DC New 52 may be "in-your-face!" with how different it is from previous incarnations of characters, Superman is a little bit of salve for the longtime fan's troubled soul.

With art by Dan Jurgens and a script by Keith Giffen, this book contains a story that could very easily have made it's way into the pages of a Superman book anywhere between 1986 and 2012. Superman saves a russian submarine from sinking, but there is something more than meets the eye. Clark receives grief from Lois for failing to pick up her sister at the airport. In his defense, he was kind of possessed by an alien consciousness at the time. Superman squares off against a mysterious new foe with daddy issues.

It is a throwback book in almost every sense of the word. While some fans may feel irritated that a flagship title like Superman isn't doing more to move the overall story of the DCU forward, the book's relative strengths as a stand-alone title hearken back a few years to when not every story needed to impact a wider universe in order to be enjoyable.

The script is simple and straightforward, without a lot of the depth that goes into something like Scott Snyder's Batman or Grant Morrison's Action Comics. We do see a carryover of the more "worldly" Superman here, as he does carry some mental concerns over not starting any sort of international incident when asked to leave Russian territorial waters.

The book's greatest strength, it's simplicity, is also it's greatest weakness. There is not a lot of meat to this tale. It is a cut and dried super hero action tale with a dash of personal drama.

Jurgens' art has not evolved much in the decades since he was last on Superman, and the style is beginning to show it's age. The style of line-work that he employs seems somewhat ill-suited to the richness of color that is being employed, and leaves the final product looking somewhat muddled. Some of this may a result of Jurgens being responsible only for the pencils, as his work on Booster Gold seemed a great deal cleaner.

All-in-all, an enjoyable story, but nothing truly special in this book.

Other reviews for Superman #9 - Secrets & Lies

    Solid As A Submarine 0

    So that cover is DRASTICALLY different from the original solicit, and while the overall design is pretty lackluster, this is one of the RARE cases where added text actually makes the cover BETTER. Initially I saw the design and I was like, uh? Then I read the caption and I was intrigued.I still wish Dan Jurgens was on full art duties instead of Jesus Merino doing the finishes, but it looks a bit better this time around. It looks more like the Dan Jurgens I know. But really, Norm Rapmund on inks ...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    "Dad" 0

    THE GOOD: I think that art looks okay in this issue Dan Durgens in doing it with some finishes by Jesus Merino. I really like the panels that take place under the water. I think that the bubbles around him are really cool. I also like the amount of details that they add to the city in the backgrounds. The story has been done before, but this feels a little original. We get to see Superman save a Russian sub. Then we get to see a blogger trying to tell Lois Lane that Superman has a secret identit...

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.