the_mighty_monarch's Superman #9 - Secrets & Lies review

Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch

Solid As A Submarine

So that cover is DRASTICALLY different from the original solicit, and while the overall design is pretty lackluster, this is one of the RARE cases where added text actually makes the cover BETTER. Initially I saw the design and I was like, uh? Then I read the caption and I was intrigued.

I still wish Dan Jurgens was on full art duties instead of Jesus Merino doing the finishes, but it looks a bit better this time around. It looks more like the Dan Jurgens I know. But really, Norm Rapmund on inks would pretty much fix the problem entirely.

Giffen's gotten a bit better at Superman's inner voice, but he still goes a little overboard with the 'tongue in cheek' humor. Especially Giffen's favorite overused sarcastic remark, "Not TOO X." I guess I can't technically fault this issue on it, but I'm sick and tired of Giffen using that phrase ALL THE DAMN TIME. I think it's a weak sarcastic remark, and I've seen enough of it to last 3 lifetimes thanks to Giffen. I'm also not sure how I feel about his Lois Lane. I'm not sure I buy that she's skeptical about Superman having a secret identity, I would've thought she'd be the first one to want to see a human side to him. But I have to say, Giffen completely NAILED Jimmy Olson.

The storyline here is a culmination of a lot of things all set up in this issue. It works surprisingly well, and the cover receives more of a long term foreboding tone, as we know SOMETHING is suspicious about that sub, but get very little clues on what it is. Then Anguish shows up (I guess Masochist was too 'controversial' or something?). I mean, 'Anguish' sounds kinda cliche, Masochist is a little more interesting and unusual. Either way, she brings a lot of interesting possibilities into the spotlight with the continual freudian slips she makes. Meanwhile we've got a blogger who thinks he's gotten proof on Superman's secret identity. I'd like to know what it is, because the implications brought upon by it ties everything together in a neat bow, funneling all the loose ends of this issue straight into the solid rope of the next one.

In Conclusion: 3.5/5

It's still really solid, it's still FAR better than any of Perez's first six issues, the story and pacing and art are all improved from the previous two issues... but something is still missing to bring this up to 'great.' Part of it is Giffen's script for Superman's inner monologue. He's a little too silly at times, so he doesn't always feel like 'Superman.'

Other reviews for Superman #9 - Secrets & Lies

    Capeless Crusader Reviews "Superman #9" 0

    While the rest of the DC New 52 may be "in-your-face!" with how different it is from previous incarnations of characters, Superman is a little bit of salve for the longtime fan's troubled soul.With art by Dan Jurgens and a script by Keith Giffen, this book contains a story that could very easily have made it's way into the pages of a Superman book anywhere between 1986 and 2012. Superman saves a russian submarine from sinking, but there is something more than meets the eye. Clark receives grief ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    "Dad" 0

    THE GOOD: I think that art looks okay in this issue Dan Durgens in doing it with some finishes by Jesus Merino. I really like the panels that take place under the water. I think that the bubbles around him are really cool. I also like the amount of details that they add to the city in the backgrounds. The story has been done before, but this feels a little original. We get to see Superman save a Russian sub. Then we get to see a blogger trying to tell Lois Lane that Superman has a secret identit...

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.