guttridgeb's Superior Spider-Man #1 - Hero or Menace? review

Avatar image for guttridgeb
  • Score:
  • guttridgeb wrote this review on .
  • 5 out of 6 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • guttridgeb has written a total of 7 reviews. The last one was for Cross World
  • This review received 3 comments

Disappointingly Brilliant

Until two days ago, I had no intention of reading this comic. Like so many others, I hate what Dan Slott has done to Peter Parker - one of my favourite super heroes. As such, I struggled to come into this with an open mind. However, as the score I gave it suggests, I believe I was successful. This truly was a superior Spider-Man comic.

This is the kind of comic I consider to be a perfect read. The mix of fight scenes and plot development was very well done. We got to see Spider-Ock expertly fighting the Sinister Six in addition to an intriguing plot line to go with it.

My main worry about the new direction of Spider-Man comics was that the humour that first made me love Spider-Man would be gone. Thankfully, I found Superior Spider-Man to be just as funny as Amazing Spider-Man, if not funnier. Hopefully, the same will be the case for Avenging Spider-Man next week and the future of Spider-Ock.

The art too was brilliant. I can be incredibly picky about art in comics and have put artists into five tiers of approval. Only two artists have made it into tier 5, the top tier. Ryan Stegman's work is some of the best I have seen and, if his work continues at this high standard, I plan on adding him to tier 5. I'm sure he'll be honoured.

That said, it wasn't flawless. The new Spider-Ock costume looks really good but there is one panel with Peter-Ock in which he looks pretty ridiculous. I'm not sure whether it was deliberately so in order to be humorous but being the art perfectionist that I am, I had to complain.

Regardless of my distaste for Spider-Ock, this was a brilliant issue. I would still rather have the real Peter Parker back in his body (the last few panels gave me hope) but as this is an inevitably temporary thing, I am happy with it for now. I recommend it to Spider-Ock fans and haters alike and I give it 5/5.

Other reviews for Superior Spider-Man #1 - Hero or Menace?

    The New Spider-Man 0

    WARNING THIS WILL SPOIL THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #700!After the way The Amazing Spider-Man #700 ended my high hopes for this series lowered dramatically, and I wasn't actually sure what I'd think of it, and was considering not getting it at all. I eventually decided to try this series, with the hope that it would be good, and that Peter would return as Spider-Man sooner rather than later (like I assume most Spider-Man fans who had a similar reaction to ASM #700 did).PlotThis issue sees the introdu...

    14 out of 14 found this review helpful.

    Doctor Octopus really isn't likeable. 0

    I like many people was very apprehensive about this series since Doctor Octopus is now Spider-man and is controlling Peter Parker’s body but I’m not one of the people who absolutely cannot stomach this sure I don’t like it but I won’t write death threats to Dan Slott because of this (seriously if you have you’re an idiot ok you don’t write Death threats because a comic characters died ok!). This actually is the first Spider-man series I am getting as I never got apart from Amazing Spider-man #70...

    10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.