@mrpandaman:
Lobdell established Starfire as the most cognicient and smartest of the 3 especially in issue 4 where she did warn Jason and Roy about the trap they were about to walk into.
Just like it was Nightwing, Starfire, and Arsenal, it is going to be Red Hood, Starfire, and Roy Harper. This is something familiar to Starfire. On a planet where she feels most people will discriminate against her, this for Starfire is where she feels she belongs.
As Starfire said, she doesn't live in the past, but she does appreciate it and that doesn't mean she cannot have things that remind her of her past.
It just seems that you just wanted to hate Red Hood and the Outlaws from the get-go. I don't see how the things revealed in this issue are fixing "bad" writing when it has been made clear that this was the plan from the start.
Being "smart" has nothing to do with Starfire warning Roy and Jason about the trap. Lobdell said that Starfire was an "animal in a woman's body". (BTW, when Lobdell was describing Starfire, he never used the word "smart". He said she was a deus ex machina, powerhouse, sexy, alien (catchall for all of the walking contradictions which make up the new Starfire even though she doesn't LOOK like an alien- heck, she looks like a modern SUPERMODEL - Even the original Kory had huge cat-like eyes, which emphasized the fact that they were pupil-less, or necessarily act in a way which is alien - I'm free and I like to have meaningless sex isn't, in fact, "alien". It's wishful thinking for frat boys.), and "an ANIMAL". Maybe, rather than out thinking those traps, the "animal" instincts took over and she was able to sense the traps.
And I'm no expert in Lobdell's writing, but he seems to have her say one thing, and act in another. She's not living in the past, but she's surrounded by those costumes which she sniffs in order to remind her of "something" from the past. It's not like she was getting on with her life in issue six. She was hiding in her familiar alien "cave" and sniffing old clothes. And so that "familiarity" makes sense in the "animal" scenario.
As to my not liking the Outlaws from the start, that's not necessarily true. When I found out that Starfire would be featured in a new book, I was thrilled. I saw the costume, I didn't complain. I defended it as a fantasy costume in a superhero comic for a solar strength character. But then I started getting information about the book. The character. The "past". And then I became discouraged. And then the first issue came out, and one of my favorite characters was reduced to "Can I do anything else for you", and "I'm bored. Wanna have sex?", and the ridiculous posing...and this is how one of my favorite characters is presented in the debut issue. I get why Lobdell did it. It was to drum up readership.It was to fabricate a controversy. But some of the fans aren't happy that he did it this way.
And let's be honest. There are some 'Fans" who have been saying: See, something happened. Everything's fine." "See, she's wearing clothes. Everything's fine. She told a joke, everything's fine. She can lift two guys. Everything's fine. You know what would have been "fine"? If Koriand'r wasn't presented in a way which was such a mockery of an alien, a princess and a super-heroine.
Log in to comment