Stan Lee a Fake...?

Avatar image for thegodofthunder
#1 Posted by TheGodofThunder (693 posts) - - Show Bio

Ok, I know that stan lee co-created a bunch of characters and what not, but I've been seeing a lot of stan lee hate. Why is that? What exactly happened between stan lee and jack kirby?

Avatar image for thecrowbar
#2 Posted by TheCrowbar (4397 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheGodofThunder: People hate success.

Avatar image for 7am_waking_up_in_the_morning
#3 Posted by 7am_Waking_Up_In_The_Morning (3947 posts) - - Show Bio

Jack Kirby was just an artist and penciler when he started. He was the guy that was drawing the concepts when Stan was telling him what to draw. After a few years, Kirby started his own character mostly known as the Celestial Race and other cosmic characters.

Avatar image for onemoreposter
#4 Posted by Onemoreposter (4365 posts) - - Show Bio

@7am_Waking_Up_In_The_Morning said:

Jack Kirby was just an artist and penciler when he started. He was the guy that was drawing the concepts when Stan was telling him what to draw. After a few years, Kirby started his own character mostly known as the Celestial Race and other cosmic characters.

Stan never told Kirby "what to draw". Stan had alot of ideas for many now famous/essential marvel characters, sure. Jack is the one who designed them. Additionally, Jack helped create back stories, define powers, and plot story arcs.

@TheGodofThunder said:

Ok, I know that stan lee co-created a bunch of characters and what not, but I've been seeing a lot of stan lee hate. Why is that? What exactly happened between stan lee and jack kirby?

I haven't hated on him personally. Dude had some novel thoughts. Kirby, in his time, and definitely money wise, didn't get the respect or recognition he deserved. If people are hating on Lee in regards to Kirby, it probably has to do with that.

There is a reason we call him King Kirby. I'm focusing on Marvel because that's where he focused the largest part of his talent IMO, but that man is responsible for defining an industry.

Avatar image for lexluthor
#5 Posted by LexLuthor (101 posts) - - Show Bio

According to the Kirby documentary found on the 2007 SE of Fantastic Four, one of the biggest issues Kirby had with Marvel as well as DC, was that both companies refused to allow Kirby and other artists the artwork they would submit to be returned to them. It's been said Kirby felt Stan could have done something to sway Marvel to give back Kirby's artwork, but Stan remained quiet on the subject which caused some resentment on Kirby's part. In addition to that, much of Kirby's time with Marvel/DC also refused to acknowledge any sort of royalty/payment in regards to character's created or co-created by artists like Kirby as well.

Of course this would eventually change, but Kirby's prime years were essentially not nearly as rewarding for artists as they would later come to be.

Avatar image for crash_recovery
#6 Posted by Crash_Recovery (855 posts) - - Show Bio

A lot of people don't understand "Marvel Style" and how Stan Lee worked. Stan would talk to a partner like Jack Kirby "I'm thinking of a guy, he's like a bug character...make something up". The average "script" presented to Ditko, Kirby and crew was "The Fantastic Four meets a moleman and fights him. I'll add the words later".

In Early, un-inked Jack Kirby pages (which are rare) you can see words that Kirby put to page himself, essentially creating the script and fleshing out the characters. Stan would then come in later, say what words should go in which panel, and apparently get full credit.

Avatar image for loki9876
#7 Posted by Loki9876 (3366 posts) - - Show Bio

Stan was an important person in comics, other guys were too but Stan Lee is more famous because of his cameos and sh@zz

Avatar image for kasino
#8 Posted by kasino (2064 posts) - - Show Bio

they both were thieves

X-Men(Doom Patrol)/Spider-Man(Spider Woman)/Captain America(The Shield)/Punisher(Mack Bolan/Black terror)/Mr.Fantastic(plastic Man)/Cyclops(Comet) were all rip-off

try not to idolize anyone

Avatar image for matchstick
#9 Posted by Matchstick (568 posts) - - Show Bio

@kasino said:

they both were thieves

X-Men(Doom Patrol)/Spider-Man(Spider Woman)/Captain America(The Shield)/Punisher(Mack Bolan/Black terror)/Mr.Fantastic(plastic Man)/Cyclops(Comet) were all rip-off

try not to idolize anyone

I see someone's been reading Cracked.

Avatar image for z3ro180
#10 Posted by z3ro180 (8778 posts) - - Show Bio
No Caption Provided
No Caption Provided

@kasino:

Avatar image for kasino
#11 Posted by kasino (2064 posts) - - Show Bio

@Matchstick: one of my favorite sites but always knew it, how obvious could it be

if you seen it then you should have mentioned it

@Z3RO180: banned for being right? Invalid how, Stan lee a fake(state or question) either I agree or answered yes

but I'm not saying he should be hated pretty cool guy and before I was old of enough to put things together he was comic God

but as i got older not comic god but comic ambassador

Avatar image for z3ro180
#12 Posted by z3ro180 (8778 posts) - - Show Bio

@kasino: i dount think your opinion on him being a fake and his characters being rip offs is valid and or and opinion

Avatar image for matchstick
#13 Posted by Matchstick (568 posts) - - Show Bio

@Z3RO180 said:

@kasino: i dount think your opinion on him being a fake and his characters being rip offs is valid and or and opinion

It is valid though. Lee got a lot of credit that belonged to other people. He's basically the Flavor Flav of comics. A whole lot of hype, but not that much talent. Why do you think he hasn't produced anything noteworthy on his own?

Avatar image for superguy0009e
#14 Posted by Superguy0009e (2404 posts) - - Show Bio

Someone lock this down.

Stan Lee, like it or not, had a huge influence on comics. He helped bring in numerous characters still in use today. Did he copy? I don't know. Did he do it all on his own? I don't care. The characters he help influenced me and hundreds of others. I don't care if Stan is fake because his characters are pretty damn important.

Avatar image for crash_recovery
#15 Posted by Crash_Recovery (855 posts) - - Show Bio

I never said I thought Stan Lee was a fake, a fraud, or a copycat. I just pointed out that his collaborators deserve at least as much credit as he does, and that perhaps he's received a bit too much "creator" credit.

Avatar image for doctor_____
#16 Posted by Doctor!!!!! (2135 posts) - - Show Bio

The title... It just made me MAD!

Avatar image for crash_recovery
#17 Posted by Crash_Recovery (855 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm well past being upset by titles.

I'm more surprised by some of the really crappy grammar and general lack of control of the English language I see.

Avatar image for yai_inn
#18 Posted by Yai_Inn (361 posts) - - Show Bio

  

Avatar image for kasino
#19 Posted by kasino (2064 posts) - - Show Bio

@Z3RO180: how is it not valid? the thread ask WHY stan lee is fake, I gave a answer to why someone would consider him such.

the "and or and opinion" part i just don't understand

again he just went from comic god to me but comic ambassador, nothing wrong with that the bridge from the mainstream to the comic world

Avatar image for thegodofthunder
#20 Posted by TheGodofThunder (693 posts) - - Show Bio

@Doctor!!!!!: I didn't mean to make you mad, lol. I just wanted to get some clarity on the subject.

Avatar image for stevon
#21 Posted by stevon (1327 posts) - - Show Bio

@Crash_Recovery said:

A lot of people don't understand "Marvel Style" and how Stan Lee worked. Stan would talk to a partner like Jack Kirby "I'm thinking of a guy, he's like a bug character...make something up". The average "script" presented to Ditko, Kirby and crew was "The Fantastic Four meets a moleman and fights him. I'll add the words later".

In Early, un-inked Jack Kirby pages (which are rare) you can see words that Kirby put to page himself, essentially creating the script and fleshing out the characters. Stan would then come in later, say what words should go in which panel, and apparently get full credit.

I thought that the dialogue Kirby and the other Marvel artists added were reminders to Stan regarding what they'd talked about in plot conferences though. At least, that's what John Romita said about it.

Avatar image for loganx360
#22 Posted by LoganX360 (197 posts) - - Show Bio

Stanlee wasnt an actual creator , he was the intern after school program kid that chilled at real comic book writers small office in newyork , he got high off of old comic book print ink & made jokes for the writers / creators . After a lot of "" Michael Jackson " they dont care about us " ...," Court Cases & Back stabbing . i.e Jimlee left marvel with the rest of the Silvestri & company . StanLee is left standing with the rights to most characters in the marvel universe . which he ended up selling to Hollywood via Disney & turned over the marvel universe to homo-topia's of DC comic universe , do the history & research & check who writes todays marvel comics & horrible art work since the year Y2k & forward .

Peace :)

Avatar image for furiousweasel
#23 Posted by FuriousWeasel (159 posts) - - Show Bio

Not only did Stan create some of comics most beloved characters (Spider-Man/Daredevil/Hulk/Iron Man/Fantastic Four/Original X-Men/Avengers etc) and concepts (No stupid kid sidekicks/realistic heroes with real personalities and real life problems/shared universe etc) if it wasn't for him no writer or artists would get any recognition. Before Stan took control, writers and artists were not even credited on comic books, it was him that started printing their names and 'Bigging them up' though his soapbox. The man is an absolute legend and we all owe him a debt of gratitude for almost single-handedly creating the blueprints of the industry we all love. I seriously can't understand anyone who dislikes like him, it just doesn't make any sense.

Avatar image for i_madc_imageguy_
#24 Posted by I'maDC/ImageGuy! (1636 posts) - - Show Bio
Loading Video...

@Yai_Inn:

Avatar image for amp___seeker_of_lost_knowledge
#25 Posted by AMP - Seeker of Lost Knowledge (1363 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheGodofThunder: Simple...Stan Lee was taking all the credit for himself...and Jack Kirby was given less respect for fame when he was working for Marvel back in the 60's.

Avatar image for turoksonofstone
#26 Posted by turoksonofstone (14913 posts) - - Show Bio

@Yai_Inn said:

Stan Lee was Simon and Kirbys office gopher in the Golden Age no one knows any comic history it seems.

Avatar image for toomuchshade
#27 Posted by TooMuchShade (3 posts) - - Show Bio

Stan can create--he gets a lot of bad advice, i think. Note this: http://www.ign.com/articles/2000/12/12/the-stax-report-exclusive-sneak-peek-at-drifter This was his creation, lost in the dust to a lot of ideas that merely exploited his iconic status instead of giving him a vehicle to create viable new stories. This story had elements that were original in their time, some concepts to be seen later in a loose fashion in Avatar, but still a unique story that highlighted his flair for making the humanity of the characters more important than their super powers. It's true that he benefited greatly from collaboration, with Kirby, et. al., but his contributions were solid.

Avatar image for night_thrasher
#28 Posted by Night Thrasher (3820 posts) - - Show Bio

Stan Lee was an awesome talent and co creator of the majority of the Marvel Universe. Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko along with Lee could be considered the Holy Trinity of the Marvel Universe. The thing is that when people want to give credit to either Ditko or Kirby especially they seem to feel that they need to discredit Stan Lee for some reason. Without Lee, Ditko or Kirby are not as important to comics as they are now and vice versa. The three of them had a symbiotic relationship that elevated the medium to places were six of the top 50 grossing movies of all time are based on their work.

Avatar image for elicrofoot
#29 Posted by EliCrofoot (51 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for thorson
#30 Posted by THORSON (4973 posts) - - Show Bio

i don't think he came up with them himself.

Avatar image for mister_surreal
#31 Posted by Mister_Surreal (12189 posts) - - Show Bio

Stan Lee got a lot of fame when characters were being made despite the fact that his partners did just as much work as he did. If not more. While Stan Lee got all of the glory, he let Steve Ditco and Jck Kirby get left behind. Behind many success stories, there was theft.

Avatar image for dailypunch
#32 Edited by DailyPunch (1 posts) - - Show Bio

The Marvel legend Stan Lee dies at the age of 95. He was known for bringing the pop culture revolution in the superhero flick and co-created some of the most iconic fictional characters such as Doctor Strange, Spiderman, Black Panther and Fantastic Four. Lee, the uncrowned king of comic books, was suffering from several ailments for the past few years, he passed away early Monday in Los Angeles.

Avatar image for kpp550
#33 Edited by kpp550 (4 posts) - - Show Bio

First of all.

Was Stanley able to draw I mean every time search for that on internet, internet tells me he was mainly the voice of character although he created characters but he never drew them while their creation.

What I mean is he created them by giving them properties , powers or whatever. In the end it was the drawer or illustrator who made those characters as we see them today,

I doesn't mean Stanley never corrected characters by telling its illustrator.

So is Stanley fake ? No.

He was the voice of marvel characters but he never 100 percently designed them (I mean he might have designed 60%, but never 100%).

While illustrators never got the praise.

they should get.

That is also true.

Here read the thus thread,

https://amp.reddit.com/r/comicbooks/comments/1030f8/did_stan_lee_actually_draw_his_famous_marvel/

So if anyone is asking if he drew those characters then no,no no and no.

But we can't say that he never told illustrator about corrections in characters or how he wanted a character.

Sometimes I wonder why there is not a system like Japanese in america, I mean u r writer then ur work goes to editor then he tells u if ur work need improvement and other things.

Rest in peace Stan Lee.

Avatar image for kinglouie
#34 Posted by KingLouie (3586 posts) - - Show Bio

Basically Thomas Edison?

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.