Dude, just stop. I can't take anymore awful castings.

Alright, who would you cast?

I actually really like McMahon but he's wrong for this part. He doesn't do "dignified and sinister" very well, as evidenced by his failure as Dr. Doom. He needs to play a character with swagger. Honestly if he were younger he'd make an adequate Hal Jordan, but Sinestro? Certainly not. Mark Strong is the best Sinestro we're ever going to get, but sadly since it looks like GL is getting wiped from the DCCU we'll probably lose him forever.

Ken Watanabe from The Last Samurai as Sinestro and Wes Bentley from American Beauty as Jason Todd

@spideyivydaredevilfan26: Hi pot, I'd like you to meet kettle. :D

@joygirl: What happened to Doctor Doom in those movies is so not his fault. Also, Doctor Doom and Sinestro are so not the same character.

That is just so wrong. Sinestro could be portrayed by either Mark Strong (which happened) or Jason Isaacs (which also happened but it was just his voice).

I liked both the Dr. Doom and the Sinestro movie versions.

Mark Strong needs to come back

He really needs to , he was amazing.