Vader wins for a solid majority, especially in the Force. Between collapsing cathedrals while severely injured (he was also in the underlevels of the building), stomping groups of Jedi, collapsing gargantuan trees, bringing down enormous mining machines, destroying huge droids, throwing empty cargo containers, parts of a ship and pieces of equipment, etc he should be far more powerful than Mace. In addition, if we want to include his TFU feats from both novels and game cutscenes (I don't know wether they're Legends or not, however), he stomped Rahm Kota (who was powerful enough to detach parts from a facility, shatter every viewport in a command center vith a Force Wave and deflect Force Lightning), briefly chocked Starkiller, levitated massive platforms high in the air and then brought them down, and Force gripped a more powerful version of Starkiller while not trying to kill him (and that's one of the reasons why Vader lost).
He could also arguably win with TP if it wasn't for the fact that he doesn't use it often in combat, considering that he has mentally raped other Force sensitives 20+ years before achieving his peak in power, possibly by using Force Horror or Memory Walk (the results of the feat seem a bit too extreme for just being the basic Force Fear), drained knowledge from powerful Jedi, etc. In lightsaber skill, he and Windu should be close, with Mace being still superior. I personally see Vader winning 7 or 8 times out of 10 and, if he is clever enough to use his power from the beginning of the fight, he would win 10/10, if not stomp Mace with the Force.
@shootingnova From what I've seen I don't agree that Tenbrous is well ahead of Vader in power, and he seems to be only better in terms of speed and knowledge. I personally would put them on the same level for now, but we'll see.
Log in to comment