I think Clayface could actually win this unless something happens and he lands in a heaping load of water. Can't the Hulk be suffocated? Sure, that might not fully "kill" Hulk but would that at least count as a win?
Batman is smarter, faster, stronger, richer, more agile, a great detective, has more skills, has better tech, better training, has even prettier love interests, and is overall far more popular. Exactly how Bond is to get even a decent amount of votes is beyond me.
@I`m Not Matezoide: Joker won against Lex Luthor, beat the snot out of Harvey Dent at least once. I don't know the circumstances of the battle against Dent, but then he also killed or hospitalized that goon in jail. Joker can quite easily kill with his bare hands, but I'm willing to admit that Zsasz is better at that and especially with a knife.
" Now I love Zsasz, don't get me wrong... but I am going with the Joker hands down. As Ultimate here has shown, the Joker does have the ability to fight. Regardless if it was straight hand to hand combat, the key thing to remember is the Joker is a talker. It is never simply hand to hand with him. He brings everything mentally to a fight that he can muster. "
Joker doesn't always flap his gums, and he knows Zsasz well enough to know that he'll most likely ignore anything he says. Now the thing here is who gets the first strike, because whoever does has a clear advantage. Joker can be relentless but like I said, so is Zsasz and Zsasz apparently knows all the right weak spots. I'll give the majority to Zsasz, but I still think Joker can pull a few wins. Now give Joker prep or a better weapon and Zsasz is just screwed.