The issue with judging the Slender Man's combat capabilities is that it's feats are all over the place and due to it's nature it is portrayed in a different way by every single person who writes about it. The only common theme running through the Mythos is that Slender Man always wins. Every time, no matter how hard you fight or how well prepared you think you are. The only problem is that the Doctor has the same thing going for him-he never really loses.
Feats
Slender Man at his strongest (typically in the blogs) is probably as dangerous as anything the Doctor has ever faced. Absolutely immortal (not truly alive, but can never die), invincible and for all intents and purposes a fully powered Eldritch Abomination capable of whatever it puts it's mind to. At his weakest (I'd say Marble Hornets), he still almost always displays intangibility, the ability to manipulate time as well as the aforementioned amortality. It's biggest weakness appears to be sheer stupidity: whether it's portrayed as a deity in and of itself or just a foe only dangerous due to the weakness of it's targets, Slender Man typically shows no desire to actually use it's power to accomplish anything. Some interpretations do portray it as intelligent, but it's impossible to say for certain.
The Doctor has the advantage of 50 years worth of feats (yes, he wasn't on air for a lot of that but material kept on coming) which are sufficient in scope to make a valid argument that the Doctor can beat literally anything below the Living Tribunal and top-tier abstracts (maybe an exaggeration, but you get the idea) He's a walking plot device only constrained by his morals-and when you consider that Slender Man targets helpless people and children most of all, I doubt his morals will apply.
Conclusion
I'm actually leaning towards a stalemate here.
Point 1: The Doctor's extremely unlikely to use the Bad Wolf, no matter what his morals are like, so I'm ignoring that unless we go with the 'Slender Man is Godlike'' description, as something like that would prompt the Doctor to go all-out. On the other hand, the Bad Wolf is a being with absolute dominion over time. As the Slender Man is often portrayed as existing outside of time, it's possible (although unlikely) that the Bad Wolf would be useless against the Slender Man. If this is the case, Slender Man cannot be defeated, only bound-and with the Slender Man's superior combat skills, I would argue that in a case like this a Godlike Slenderman would be beyond the Doctor's capacity to seal.
Point 2: Slender Man wears a snappy suit. However, it is probable that the power of the Doctor's fez cancels this out, giving the Doctor's bowtie the time it needs to take Slender Man out.
Point 3: Prep is crucial. Without prep, Slender Man wins this so fast it's a spite battle. It's portrayed as strong enough to tear apart entire squads of soldiers with absolute ease, it has sufficient mind control powers to take over his companions, which could lead to the Doctor being weakened further by a Heroic BSOD and finally even the Marble Hornet's Slender Man has shown itself to be capable of telporting others so if could win simply via BFR. The fact is that the Doctor has relatively few combat options without prep.
Point 4: The Doctor has taken out far better. Arguably via massive application of the glory that is PIS, but it's still a hugely important point.
Point 5: The Slender Man has consistently shown itself to be above both the laws of physics and, more importantly, capable of utterly negating or manipulating the effects of technology. It's possible that this could affect all of the Doctor's gadgets (except of course the Tardis) Unlikely, but worth a mention.
I'm a huge fan of both the Mythos and Dr Who, but I think that the problem is Slender Man is so different in every show or blog, too different to even class it as one character. With power levels as nebulous as his, I think that it might be better for Slender Man to be banned from the Battles section.
If Slender Man is at maximum power and the Doctor has prep: Slender takes it but barely
If Slender Man is at minimum power and the Doctor has prep: Doctor destroys.
If Slender Man is at any power level and this is a random encounter: Slender slaughters.
If the battle takes place in a Doctor Who episode: It's a two-parter where the Doctor finally manages to lock the Slender Man out of the continuum , effectively rendering it impotent. Companion probably dies.
Overall, stalemate but I really feel that Slender Man battles just shouldn't happen because it has literally never lost, so we have no idea how much power is necessary to take it out. The argument is of course that it only appears to be infinitely powerful because it exists in a superpower free world, but we can never really know for certain.
Log in to comment