• ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Star Wars Tournament: Top 50 Most Powerful Force Users. on the Battles board

    We've got the likes of Aurra Sing, so why not Aayla Secura? Or for that matter, Quinlan Vos from Legends.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @erkan12: The fact that Yoda thought Obi-Wan was a fairly appropriate matchup for Anakin or had a better chance at killing him than Sidious doesn't mean anything. Obi-Wan and Anakin's relationship mak...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @erkan12: That your argument is invalid? Obi-Wan being able to find Anakin means absolutely nothing, lol.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @erkan12 said:''Destroy the Sith we must, to fight with this Lord Sidious strong enough you're not. Twisted by the Dark Side, young Skywalker has become. The boy you trained, gone he is... Consumed by...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @greysentinel365: Ah, ok. You guys don't have DST up there, so that explains the hour's difference.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @greysentinel365: It was about 6. Daylight saving here in NSW. You from QLD or WA?

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Yoda. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker said:"There’s up to eight levels. Yoda is an eight, Mace Windu is an eight, Obi is a seven, but if you miss a level, it’s a bit like taking drugs to get enlightenment.” Anakin is the pe...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Bane vs Darth Zannah. on the Battles board

    @lordofthelight: Partly serious. After she tripped she was saved by the dark side power lurking beneath Ambria. Otherwise it's likely she would have lost, imo.@kbroskywalker said:Didn't Bane manage to...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Luke Skywalker (Dark Empire) vs Darth Vader. on the Battles board

    Luke should take it comfortably. He's already experienced in fighting Vader's form, and greatly improved since RotJ when he fought Vader on an even footing.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker:Well, yes, in legends he's an inferior duelist.Yes, and we're discussing Legends.Again, you're forcing a specification which isn't there. The context says nothing about "becoming very g...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Bane vs Darth Zannah. on the Battles board

    Well, on neutral ground Zannah wouldn't have tripped on the graves and probably would have been able to court the duel until she could unleash the charged spell, which Bane would probably die to given...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker:I'm not arguing anything regarding Vader. I'm exclusively talking about Kenobiin terms of a combative force user. Not that deepening your connection to the source of your power wouldn't...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darsha Assant vs Bengel Morr. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker: I guess it's kind of true, but Oneness isn't just a matter of going all-out. Most of the time you don't really choose to enter Oneness; it's involuntary.Although that would make Darsha...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker:Actually, when we look at the novelization, Kenobi mentioning he's grown much is in response to his belief that Vader has also matured much and right afterwards, Kenobi contemplates the...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darsha Assant vs Bengel Morr. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker: No, it's pretty much TPM Maul.@lordofthelight said: Darsha was in "Oneness" at the time( it's made pretty obvious), and still performed( and was stated to be, in comparison to Maul) si...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darsha Assant vs Bengel Morr. on the Battles board

    Darsha didn't perform too badly against Maul if I recall correctly, whereas Bengel was thrashed by a HoT using a training blade and with two Flesh Raiders by his side. Darsha probably stomps.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker: Which they are, being strictly between Obi-Wan and Maul. Unless you seriously think Obi-Wan three-shotting Maul came down purely to a skill gap.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @lordofthelight: That's agreeable. In essence, he grew more powerful (doesn't make sense for him to grow less so) from his studies of the Living Force, but a lack of saber practice and specific applic...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker: Because the "growth" can be circumstantial, as it is here.Where's the citation for Yoda and Sidious? The two scenarios are hardly similar anyway so this is probably Filoni pulling some...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Why was Obi Wan Kenobi able to contend with Darth Vader on Mustafar- Some additional context and elaboration. on the Battles board

    @kbroskywalker: I've already discussed the nature of the evidence you cited from Filoni. None of them say what you think they do, and none of them apply outside of Obi-Wan vs Maul.