Both have all their powers. Note: Popeye might not be Superman or freakish, but his feats prove he can lift several tens of tons maybe more, run at supersonic speeds, and hit someone to the other side of the planet, even the moon. Popeye debuted in 1919 as a comic book character, so this is legit. Superman due to planet smashing feats would probably beat Popeye unless Popeye ate lots and lots of Spinach or something.... But logically he sould be able to hang in there with non-cosmic level people like Aquaman. Who wins this brawl. There is no spinach shortage and it teleports directly into Popeye. Aquaman has teleporting water to keep him fully hydrated. Both can breathe/hold their breath indefinitely underwater. Who wins?