Scooby Doo: Mystery Incorporated Review
By SaintWildcard 14 Comments
So I've recently gone through the entire series Scooby Doo Mystery Incorporated again for kicks. I had gone through the entire series a while back and loved it then. Now upon rewatching it, I've come to appreciate it even more. While not entirely perfect, it's possibly the best interpretation of the characters we've seen to date. In an era where people consistently complain about Reboots, this is one done right. Where I think most people take issue with reboots is, that they take a beloved property that tend to be classics done right the first time, and then try to rehash the story. What this show does is, take a show that was never that deep or complex, and inject it with fleshed out characters and intricate storytelling. In other words, the bar wasn't that high to leap. That being said, the show wasn't just barely better, but this one actually tried. A ton of hard work and sweat went into this, so let's dive in to the show.
The Show
The series takes the classic set up of Scoob and the Gang, but sets them in the town of Crystal Cove while they are in high school. Right of the bat I have to say that usually taking something iconic and setting those characters in High School tends to be a bad thing (looking at you Gotham High concept art). The school stuff plays very little part in the series aside from the typical prom episode, so that may be why they never run that into the ground. The Gang for the most part is set in the town and all mysteries tend to take place within. For the most part, the convenience of this is set up really well.
This franchise is injected with a much appreciated dose of story. Instead of just settling for solving a mystery every episode, they have a mystery that runs throughout the course of the series that ties all the weird events in their town. It starts off as just a simple mystery of some missing kids and ramps up into something out of an HP Lovecraft story. A few bumps along the road, but I think the tension, intrigue and fleshed out characters make it worth those bumps. I know this came first, but it reminds me of something like Stranger Things.
The world building of this show seems like a love letter to all things horror, Scooby Doo and Hannah Barbara. The previous Mystery Inc (the group of mystery solvers before the Main Group), almost seem like jaded versions of what would happen if they Main Group broke up. The world has a certain asthetic which is a blend of 70's fashion but taking place in modern day. They also refrence things like Sealab 2020 (not 2021), Dyno Mutt, all those other Mystery Solving groups that copied the Scooby Doo formula,and much more.
The comedy in this show is *muah!* so good. This series is more aimed at older kids and adult fans of the franchise, since there is a lot of humor that some kids won't get. So many sex jokes, and even blatant sexist jokes (at the expense of men of course). Most of it stems from it's two best restructured characters, Velma and Fred, but I'll get to them in the character breakdowns. I also think that the show has a sense of self awareness and knows when to poke fun at itself, without it being too harsh.
The Characters
The show is halfway to a solid Reboot with it's great storytelling, now it's time to see if the characters are up to snuff. In order from Least to Best
Scooby & Shaggy: Probably the least changed out of the whole bunch. Scooby talks a bit more and more clearly than in other incarnations. Shaggy was dating Velma for a bit, but ended it for Scooby (what a twat). The end of that relationship was meant to contrast the growing romance between Daphne and Fred.
Daphne: When I started to get the idea for writing this review, I thought I was gonna come down on Daphne since she didn't seem all that interesting. She mostly clinged to Fred's arm and wanted his attention. After stewing over it for a bit, it has more to do with that they never went far enough into the tragedy of her character. She made for great comedic moments, but there was this ongoing theme of her being the least perfect daughter in the family, and struggling to maintain herself at all (she goes nuts for chocolate). Plus, I think something can be said about her being the most normal one in the group. I think if they had done an origin episode, it would have focused on her wanting to find a place where she belongs.
Fred: It's an amazing thing when dumbing down a character can actually be a positive thing. In previous incarnations (aside from maybe A Pup Named Scooby Doo), Fred is probably the most bland in the group. He's just a nice guy who makes traps. In this show, they take that up to 11 and now he's a clueless nice guy who loves traps. He's the kind of balance that I saw lacking in Daphne. Where he was still funny and likable, but there was a tragedy to his character.
Velma: The MVP of this series. If I was a chick, I would use her as my Avatar. Her level of wit brought a smile to my face. I even love how they gave her a tint of Jew, with her Oy's. She was basically Daria, but with a bit more joy in her. Shaggy, you messed up. I would have put a ring on that finger. While I would say that Fred in the series got the most development, Velma was the most funny. That being said, Velma was no weak link when it came to character development. She went on her own journey and as a skeptic faced a crisis of self when faced with actual supernatural elements.
The chemistry between these characters is also very solid. They can help each other when they are at their lowest, get mad and it'll be an issue for the group, or even bust each other's balls.
Some Fixes I Would Do
The show is far from perfect, but I do think it's set the bar pretty high. I can't imagine someone else doing this better, but for now I'm gonna look at some of the problems with the show.
Needed An Origin/Flesh Out Daphne- This is killing two birds with one stone. The show sets up that the reason these guys are friends, is because *redacted* wants them to be friends. I would have liked to have seen this play out in their first meet. I would have made Daphne the main focus of the episode, and show why she wants to be in this group. Play up the fact that her family hassles her all the time over not being perfect like them.
Some Motivations Make No Sense- At times it feels like the show doesn't put as much effort as to why the bad guys dress up. The show has written and tackled the villains from different angles and done them so well, so for them to drop the ball like this, feels like a flub up on their mostly spotless show. All one guy had to do was quit his job, but took to scaring .
Better Build Up To The Finale- So there's this character who turns out to know some stuff at the end. we had met him before, but the reveal came out of nowhere. Also, I would have preferred a better ending, than some power of love ending. The defeat could have been done a bit better.
Fred's "Dad"- I wanted to more development and effort put in to fixing the relationship between them. The way they did it lacked an emotional moment for me, even though they wanted to build it up as that.
What a Coincidence- There are times that certain items are found almost by shear luck. They are on this quest to find some keys. and some of them just appear out of nowhere to them.
Better Tone Management- Sometimes the shift in tone was very clunky. I'm also of the mindset that this should could have used a dash of more darkness. I think they could have played some of the moments a bit more straight, and the show still would have worked and the comedic moments would have stood out more.
Final Thoughts
Not much more I can say on this show. I think if you ever loved this franchise, and love horror, this is the show for you. It's Stranger Things meets Scooby Doo (a more accurate comparison would be Twin Peaks, but I never saw it). This show is a good blend of mystery, spookiness and comedy.
Log in to comment