Quinlan58

@dngn4774: Like I said, those were the only two of his movies he wrote, so you can't criticize or praise him for any of the others as a screenwriter. Dawn of the Dead? George Romero and James Gunn. Wa...

From my vague memories of both that I do not intend to refresh ever, Routh.

@dngn4774: According to IMDB, the only films he has both written and directed are 300 and Sucker Punch, so you can't call him a bad screenwriter on account of everything else.

Still though, I'm not the biggest fan of All-Star Superman, but refusing to release a story from the creators of Superman's most acclaimed story in his 1000th issue, in his 80th birthday, for the sake...

@castiel_18: why bring back Cell? He was by far weaker than Frieza at that point in time.

@dernman: But Aquaman is not Superman. I'm not saying that two heroes can only be that, I'm saying that the two pillars on which the DC Universe is built cannot have a regular working relationship, be...

@dernman: Why not? From a universe-building perspective, it's either that or making them uneasy allies, and there are only so many times they can work together until the second one starts to feel forc...

The puppy

And we're back to 50-50. Holy Batman, that must be some sort of achievement.

Oh yeah, the Karate Kid movie were they were explicitely not doing karate, and in fact the kid lost at the start because he was trying to use karate. How could I forget that? What were we talking abo...

@farkam said:@all-father said: Make good movies. It's that simple.

Superman. The answer is so obvious the only real discussion to be had is for GL recommendations.In which case, "DC: New Frontier", Tom King's "Will You Be My God?", Geoff Johns' run (specially "Rebirt...

@all-father: His Action Comics 1000 story and his Green Lantern one-shot were excellent. Though I didn't read them, his Grayson and Omega Men runs were highly acclaimed, if you consider Dick Grayson a...

I'm assuming because Kaguya actually wanted to cooperate with him unlike Obito.

@king_stranglehold_da_first: King is giving Batman and Catwoman crazy feats too and his run is still incredibly controversial.

@ready_4_madness: Yeah, 42 votes and still a perfect 50% split is quite an achievement.If nothing else, he's bold, faithful to his artistic vision and passionate about film in general and his movies s...

@heatforce: Kubrick took far more risks than Snyder has ever taken, though. I mean, an adaptation of Lolita, a black comedy about nuclear war and incompetent military leaders at the height of the Cold...

@zariusii: Eh, Mark Millar and Mark Waid are exactly the same (Millar's worse actually), and those two have written some amazing Superman stories, so that's not a take on Superman I mind that much. Ju...

He's pretentious, overblown, dull and has no idea of what subtlety means. I'm going to have to say no. He's not a bad one. He's simply not good either.

@zariusii: I forgive anything thehmc might have to say just for this:No. You get Superman wrong. Just wrong. "Superman is overpowered" is one of the dumbest criticisms."Oh well if Superman is that pow...