lumutness

This user has not updated recently.

16 0 0 1
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

lumutness's forum posts

  • 15 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

I actually don't have any problem with this new Kid Flash (or is this Impulse, now?) being bi-racial. Actually he got some interesting backstory, too, and he would be new addition to speedsters family as Barry's apprentice/nephew/whatever. Even if there's no Wally West here, I would somewhat accept the new Impulse. Just like Kaldur and Garth are different Aqualad.

Making him Wally West is the main problem. Yes, I agree if it's the insulting part. You'd think that they want to make this Wally being rejected by fans. I already accepted him as a different character than Wally, but it still grated my nerves when I remember his name. This is why I never pick up any Flash issues 'till now. (sorry, Imp).

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Hello! I'm a new comics reader, who is developing a headache since start reading comic, mostly because I'm researching the timeline of pre-52 first from wikipedia rather than the new one. I don't know if it's a wrong move or not... ^^; (But I'd say that I'm a proud Robin(s) fan even before reading the comic--need to know Steph more)... nevermind. Tim Drake's backstory feels really interesting and well crafted before, and he fit perfectly into the Family. I want to know him more (and his character development), but I find it hard to get digital copy of his 'Robin' and 'Red Robin' issues. Pity I can't find the continuity in new-52 since his and other Bats character reboot. :(

But that's not my point here.

So, I'm reading several new-52 Bat titles right now and I'll say that Snyder's and Capullo's Batman did it good(the one that didn't give me a massive headache). As far as I read, it still fits pre-52 continuity(don't know about Zero Year, though) with those little family-moment tucked in between.

My questions: Would pre-52 Tim Drake fit into Bat titles new-52 continuity? If the answer if yes, tell me how, and why. I need your opinion, here. :)

...Please?

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@lumutness: No, the only time we saw any members of the Batfamily mourn his death was Alfred in Nightwing #30 and Barbara Gordon in one of the Batgirl issues that was released at that time. The rest of the time and for the rest of the Bat-family, Dick's death has been met with collective indifference, almost as if the Bat-family thinks he's on a business trip and will return in a week or so, rather than him being dead.

My biggest criticism of the whole "Dick-fakes-his-death-to-join-Spyral", is just much DC Editorial bungled the impact of his death because there is none, what's frustrating is that the writers would have time in Batman Eternal to expound on Dick Grayson's death affecting the Bat-family because it's a weekly and we have seen the series struggle at times trying to think of things to do with its characters, but they didn't capitalize on what would have made for great drama. It's not as though the other writers aren't familiar with the concept of Dick Grayson joining Spyral, Tim Seeley, one of the writers of Grayson also writes for Batman Eternal. What makes it even more frustrating was that Nightwing #30 was originally going to be about the Bat-family, the Justice League and the "Outlaws" reacting to his death, but that was scratched for what was essentially Grayson #0 and that issue is the low point of Tim and Tom's collaboration.

If there is one glimmer of hope to cling onto is that no writer has wrote about the relationship Dick has with the Batfamily, especially Damian in the new 52 quite like Peter Tomasi and hopefully when Damian comes back, the reaction that Damian will have to Dick being "dead" will be....something, rather than ambivalence.

either some of them deduced that Dick Grayson is actually alive (since Bruce wasn't as crazy as he had been after Jason's death... suspicious, right?), or the editorial also forgot the importance of this one. It feels very out-of-character since he's supposed to be the heart of The Family. If they do know, that makes the whole ressurecting-Damian thing makes sense. If not, well, either they are emotionally compromised (or egoist), or they want to make Damian's second life miserable by force him to living the world where Dick Grayson is 'dead'.

If Damian really comes back in the near future (and if DC do it right), it won't be just 'something'. Damian will EXPLODE, I'm sure. Maybe to his father, too (which I doubt, knowing DC).

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Whoa, this is intense.

@the_nerd_king: it's the other way around, Jason didn't go out of his way to attack Tim because he had a different opinion, Tim Attacked Jason,Beat him with a crowbar. aslo like i said, Jason isn't going around killing people who litter. His goal was to control crime not stop it, get rid of the big names like joker, not petty criminals.

@midnightdragon18: Tim attacked Jason to save lives. And, once again, why couldn't Jason knock Tim out or something? He knows Tim isn't evil!

To get to Joker, Jason has to kill all of his minions, who are 'petty criminals'.

Jason HIMSELF is a criminal. Why does he have the right to decide wether someone lives or dies?

Oh, and in all of this, you're forgetting something: a lot of Gotham's villains are crazy. Meaning confused. Meaning in their mind, their doing what's right. Mr. Freeze: avenging his wife. Man-bat: he doesn't even have a choice. Two-face: split-personality disorder. Ventriloquist: also split-personality disorder. Riddler: wants to be respected for his genius. Are their methods extreme? Yes, but so are Jason's.

As far as I know, Jason and crowbar had personal history between them (well... you see, Joker). Even if Tim did it to save lives, Jason would still take it personally. I think it's logical.

Hmm, I always thought that Jason was supposed to be a vigilante (different kind from Batman, though). But I can't argue that development in pre-52 made him a stereotypical criminal who strays from his true path. (Namely, killing criminals who actually deserved it.) This is why I like him in new-52 more.

Eh, by the way, maybe, MAYBE Batman did attempt to kill The Joker once upon a time.Check this: http://screenrant.com/the-killing-joke-batman-killed-joker-grant-morrison/
and this: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/did-dark-knight-secretly-kill-608209

What do you think?

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#6  Edited By lumutness

I will stick with pre-52 for the backstory of the character. But, admittedly, he got better characterization in new-52. In pre-52, I feel that Battle of The Cowl arc done him no justice for made him typical villain.

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@aahz said:

@lumutness said:

Tim is... I don't know about current timeline, but he did hold a grudge to B five years later in future's end for making him a 'soldier' (for me, the way B recruited him always feels awkward and kinda out of character--shouldn't he prevent himself to have another sidekick after what happened to Jay?),

But in the new 52 Tim more or less appllied for the Robin position (and got it by nearly getting his parents killed). irrc Jason was the only one how was "recruited" by Bruce.

Yes, he did applied (with slightly different reason and a whole different method from pre-52 this time). ^^;
Besides that, from my opinion, it's Bruce's decisions that make new-52 Tim the way he is. In pre-52, Bruce is already don't like his idea to wear Robin suit (which makes him more determined since he always said that Batman needs a Robin). In new-52, B is actively offered that to Tim (hence why I use the term 'recruited'). His falling out with Batman doesn't help, either. (in pre-52, it's his falling out with Dick that made him Red Robin. but Dick and Tim is already too close, so he can't really hate Dick.)

Since in new-52 Tim never discovered Nightwing (and Batman's) identity by himself, thus made him never bonded with Dick that well, I suppose the brotherly aspect is kinda dulled? I don't know if he's secretly mourned or anything, because there's no indication that he is that I know of. Especially after Damian's (his demon-brat-little-brother) death, the loss of another (beloved) brother should've taken toll on him. At least in pre-52 it would hit him hardest, since he and Dick was very close.

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#8  Edited By lumutness

@jayc1324 said:

Yeah, batgirl and batman eternal.

which issues?

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Because DC editorial doesn't always think things through.

From the reality point of view, that's the answer. (his brother haven't even mourn him... yet?)

From the story point of view: Batman's orders.

I hope I can tell you to deal with it, but I'm still sore about that, too. ^^;

Avatar image for lumutness
lumutness

16

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

1

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Honestly, this new issue amuses me greatly. Especially when Midnighter and Dick both helping to deliver the (super?) baby. And, whoa! There's actually some big plot development (at least, I think it's big). Midnighter now knows the person behind that swirly-lolipop face. I don't know if it's good or bad thing.

Even though this isn't the best issue I read, this give me more insight about Dick Grayson as a character. He's the only character I really enjoyed (besides Alfred) since new 52, and that's because they doesn't really change. Not much. At least his personality doesn't.

The story is enjoyable, sweet, and sad. It certainly give me a break from the whole Batman tense atmosphere. For the art... I wonder how did Janin makes the panel still interesting while the setting is nothing but sand. Awesome.

Btw, is anyone in the Bat family mourning him nowadays? Besides Alfred and Barbara, I mean. ...Tim, at least? (or did new52 Tim wasn't so close with Dick as he was 'close' with Damian?)

  • 15 results
  • 1
  • 2