Kilius

Jedi Restraint Mace is slightly superior. No holding back Mace is a legit Yoda/Sidious tier fighter.And yes there is a big difference between the two Maces. Shatterpoint Mace, in a life and death situ...

I'm generally more impressed with Plagueis and Tenebrous over Anakin both of whom Sidious would beat. I'm more impressed with Sidious's emphatic domination over Maul than Anakin edging Dooku and stil...

@breakofdawn:Technically the fight can be considered C-Canon as it happens in the junior novelization: SPOILER After this Ventress surprises him with a Force push which causes him to hit the wall and...

AotC Kenobi isn't far removed from TCW Kenobi or even RotS Kenobi. The war certainly hardened him but I don't think it enhanced his skills that much, just his core. His Soresu was already advanced eno...

Two is too much. If it was sabers only maybe. Lightning makes it a lock. It only takes one to tie Anakin up while the other gets his opening to light him up.

This is legends not movie only. Gillard likely didn't read or take into account the EU which is being considered here. Jango actually was supposed to have an extended fight with Mace in the original d...

In his prime Apollo. Rocky ii Apollo was past-prime, all the motivation in the world can't turn back the clock. Apollo would be the G.O.A.T if his record was real. No one in the real boxing world real...

@mrsportsguy13: Fair enough my years were off. Gym shape isn't the same as fighting shape. Lots of ex champions work out and keep themselves in good shape, but they still can't do the same things they...

Maul should be at his peak here, unless there's any indication he deteriorated from since SoD which I don't think there is any. Maul beats him more assuredly in a fight not to different from TPM. Sim...

Ivan is an over hyped eurostiff, whos claim to fame is beating an over 40 Apollo who was on the downside even as a early as Rocky 1 and hadn't fought competively in over a decade. To put things in per...

I rate AotC Kenobi higher than I once did. He's probably closer to his peak than we care to admit. He wasn't close to 100% when he fought Dooku heavily fatigued, who would always be wrong for him even...

Ki-Adi’s best feats are putting in a game but losing effort against Grievous while fatigued. Kenobi tops this by doing pretty much the same against his master Dooku while similarly fatigued but not on...

Obi-Wan and Anakin are overrated as a duo. Their synergy is optimized for the battlefield not a single high caliber duelist. Anakin always has to carry Kenobi in their 2on1s with Dooku. He’s never had...

Make it Purge Vader and it’s a 50/50 fight. That version is superior to Vastor who beat Mace to within an inch of his life. And faster than characters who can keep pace with Maul including a post prim...

Dooku still finesses him. And even with the memory wipe Dooku should still recognize ”the hand of his training and technique” as did Mace during the latter’s brief battle on the mag-lev.Grievous wins ...

Assuming they are both performing at their best Anakin.Sixteen year old Anakin is capable of performing on Jinn’s level after he centers himself. SPOILER This means Anakin moved faster than Kenobi’s ...

Vikings are better armored and better equipped;

All incarcerations of Maul wins assuredly if Grievous duels him and doesn’t use any open appendages, relying purely on all four sabers.Grievous has a decent shot if he’s keeps his extra arms in reserv...

@lord_tenebrous: It’s like how two lightsabers is optimal for holding off two opponents than a single blade but doesn’t necessarily make you twice as better equipped to deal with a single advisory.Mau...

Jinn isn’t Maul. Maul decisively outfought Jinn with an injured limb slowing him down. If Jinn goes for broke he can pressure Bane as he did Maul in his last stand but Bane is a Soresu master, I have ...