John Valentine

Yeah, it's one of them!

X-Men forever was just terrible.

Even if the Ultimate Universe lost it's way, but the first two dozen or more issues of Ultimate X-Men were great. There were highlights later on too. Brian Wood's run was good.

Carey's run was great on the whole. Very, very good. I really enjoyed the pre-Messiah Complex issues and the post-MC Professor X issues. I do feel it became a bit too much of a Rogue solo book for me around 2009/10, but then it picked up again! Very good.

Gillen's Uncanny was great, but wish he'd had a longer run - i.e. him doing Uncanny post AvX and him doing the Cyclops Revolution.

Really? I don't think there was anything special about it. It wasn't bad, it just wasn't that great. Pretty solid but mediocre. And the best stuff from his run (Messiah Complex) was corroborative.

1. Morrison
2. Claremont
3. Carey
4. Whedon
5. Lobdell/Nicieza

He's not awful, he's just not that great. And it's a shame as I feel like it brings down the quality of the book overall.

Yeah, it looks really good actually.

It's a shame, but I'd rather have shorter and sweeter than longer and lower quality.

That book is so offensively average. Just generic Avengers shit.

X-Men TAS.

That wasn't Bryan Singer, that was Brett Ratner.

I like every member of this team. Most of all, Magneto, however.