firelordiroh

If Maul unquestionably wins this fight as some you are claiming then he should also be capable of defeating Windu. I hope yall know what this would mean, you're wanking Maul up to the point where he's...

@eldominance said:luke by logic. sids threw fight and already beat mace.He didn't because Sidious isn't strong enough to throw away a fight against Windu who is canonically capable of challenging him....

Not really convinced Vader is above the ROTS giants in canon but Luke should be winning this one.

yikes.

@uhu123 said:Round 1: 50/50, leaning Vader by a hair due to experience but it is an even split reallyRound 2: Luke 9/10, Vader is pre-prime and Mando Luke scales quite a bit above even prime VaderRou...

Legends Vader in the mud yet again.

^Pretty much this, Anakin is superior to Vader in legends but as this isn't the case in canon, Luke who is considered to be an equal if not superior to Vader in ROTJ should be able to take any Jedi ap...

@tvenger:I still believe he can take the bonus round as well, the Magnaguards won't even be a factor imo.

Anakin both rounds.

Anakin solo's if Palpatine kills Obi-Wan.

what everyone else said.

Clears.

Team 2.

@darthadi: I'm okay with people thinking that but it's a little irritating when some people act as if the circumstances didn't effect Luke either.

@void_reborn: Fair enough but Is it up to interpretation tho with the sources/statement supporting it?

@void_reborn: Good point in that Dooku does well against a better duo in Anakin and Obi-Wan but Luke is ROTJ Vader's equal in skill and power. Dooku's smarter and more experienced which could allow h...

@drunkhc:"Father and son were now equally strong with the Force, and equally skilled with their lightsabers."-Jedi vs. Sith (2016)No it's not just "headcanon', ROTJ Luke could win this fight let alone...