I forgot who said this but it was quoted by Dawkins in a doc he did. It went something like "If religion didnt exist we would have good people doing good things and bad people doing bad things but only religion can make good people do bad things."
That's a stupid quote IMO. All sorts of different ideologies can corrupt people, not just religion, and I've experienced a lot of personal self-growth and moral improvement heavily influenced by my religious perspective, and I've seen several of the most loving people I know shaped into the amazing people they are largely by their religious faith. Dawkins is being kinda dumb when he characterizes religion as some big boogeyman that is responsible for most of the world's problems, he suggests religion is the only thing can corrupt good people, and he suggests religion's only impacts are negative ones, all of which is patently false.
The four horsemen are obviously very intelligent people in their own ways, but sometimes they said some rather stupid things. For example the Dawkins quote "Why do we feel the universe owes us an explanation," which is completely disingenuous from a religious or secular perspective, or Sam Harris's belief that our self-awareness and subjective experience doesn't really exist because it can't be physically quantified.
I think the point of the quote was to show how religion is often used to justify awful acts and make people follow just because its the holy law. Religion can make people better themselves, thats true just like other ideologys can corrupt people aswell but you have to agree that most of the things that a majority of people would find bad in todays world has been due to or justified with religion in the present and the past. Dawkins does go overboard in putting all the blame on religion for the worlds problems but to be fair the things he seems to have problems with are all religious related. The question is if this is accidental or if he just cherry picks the ones that would fit his anti religious agenda.
Also I dont believe he thinks religions only impact is negative. IMO he believes the negatives far outweigh the positives which is up for discussion.
Log in to comment