Really in any moral decisive game (mostly RDR2) I try my hardest to be a good person with good honor then everything goes to shit. IMO, having bad honor is a more fun experience then having good honor.
@paragonxxx: You really should, some parts could feel long and tedious though whatever ending you work up to isn’t even that in the slightest. For most cases, the game is brutal and heart-wrenching throughout - even if you choose the peaceful path. Plus, the graphics are great, the Hostage Demo shows that. But overall, if you got the chance you should really try it!