My two cents:
Costume redesigns on decades-old characters are by default, risky territory. Heroes are defined by their costumes. Even if the redesign is objectively more practical (remove Batman's pointy ears) people will rightfully complain that the character "just isn't the same". It's futile arguing about what looks better, since a glance outside is all it takes to know that everyone has their own idea of what clothing looks good and what doesn't.
I don't like the new powergirl costume, both because I think the old outfit looks better and because I don't see a point to changing it; there isn't much difference in utility or practicality.
I hope that the motivation was not that the old costume led to objectification, because that would seem to me a fool's errand. We're supposed to objectify comic book characters. That's half the point. There's a reason why Superman doesn't have a beer gut.
These are idealized godlike creatures. The artist has to convey through their appearance that these are radiant, powerful individuals.
To this end, being physically attractive is important for both male and female characters. However because of our culture, it is more important for female ones. This is because sexiness translates to power much more for a woman than it does for a man.
When you close your eyes and think of a powerful man, he is probably attractive, but the things that connote power are more his athleticism and craft - what he seems to be able to do.
When you close your eyes and think of a powerful woman, she is probably very attractive and not overly muscular. Imagine a female body-builder. Now imagine a sexy model. Who seems more powerful? I certainly know who I'd rather be.
An attractive guy working at Mcdonalds has no chance with a wealthy female businesswoman who comes in to order lunch. Reverse the genders. The attractive woman has a chance.
Sexiness = power for women. That's just how we're wired. Catwoman as a butterface with broad shoulders and huge biceps seems much less intimidating than slender Selina with her suit zipper at her navel.
None of this is to argue that all heroines should traipse around in pasties and thongs; Indeed what made Haley Atwell so memorable in the Captain America film was her classiness - that she knew how to dress and act like a lady while being a soldier.
Would that more heroines had her class. There are more than a few heroines out there with inexplicably trashy costumes. Even still, I'm hesitant to agree with changing them in the name of not objectifying women.
Log in to comment