duo_forbidden's Power Girl #1 - Power Girl review

Avatar image for duo_forbidden

A look at Power Girl's origins

Who is Power Girl?

 The usual joke
 The usual joke

Well....that's complicated. Yes, she's Kara Zor-L, who's kind of another Supergirl from an alternate universe, but an early adult version of her. Her origin story has been retconned so many times in major events in DC such as the famous Crisis of Infinite Earths and Zero Hour, it makes her origin so inconsistent, and almost makes her a practical joke. Fortunately, all Power Girl's her origin stories are featured in this tradeback, and gives new readers a way to understand all of her origins, both the old and the new.

Showcase #97-99 (1976) written by Paul Levitz, is a classic tale of Power Girl which, both explain her original origins of being a Kryptonian and give a sense of what she was like on Earth 2. The story setup is a classic scenario that features other classic characters like  Alan Scott and Brainwave.  

 

 What?
 What?

The second story is regarded to be the more far-fetched. In Secret Origins #11 (1987) her story so that her origins are retconned, so that she's actually from the ancient city of Atlantis who was in stasis until awakened in the present. This story was done in order to fix her origin after the aftermath of Crisis of Infinite Earths. While Paul Kupperberg meant well, her Atlantian origin was just a bit too silly and to be honest, unnecessary. Her abilities are magic based? Really? If Crisis of Infinite Earths merged the two Earths together, there was no point to alternating her origin story.

The story a lot of people will turn towards to right away would be at the end. In JSA Classified #1-4 (2005) Geoff Johns restores

Power Girl's original story of being a Kryptonian from an alternative universe--this time from Earth 2 (with a few modifications, such as her age), with a twist. Thanks to the upcoming events of Infinite Crisis, Johns is able to combine both origin stories together, including some new origins that adds the Legion of Super-Heroes and the Multiverse. At first it doesn't seem to fix the initial problem, but as I said before, this is done with a twist thanks to the Psycho Pirate.

 Which origin story is true?
 Which origin story is true?

 
What I also liked about this story is that it gives readers a modern day incarnation of Power Girl, where she's trying to find her place on New Earth. Her personality is a bit different from previous versions, and it make it easier for readers, both new and old to relate to her. It's a classic case of homesickness where while she know these superheroes, she doesn't exactly know how to fit in. It's this journey that helps her accept who she is and continue to do what she does best. Of course, this wouldn't be Power Girl without poking fun of Power Girl herself There is a large cast of characters besides the JSA that appear in this story that help move the story along.

 I can understand that reasoning
 I can understand that reasoning

I was a bit put off by the artwork with the first two stories: Showcase and Secret Origins, but I appreciate the classic look for its time. Mind, this was during the 70s and 80s, so her look is a bit old fashioned. I do also like that both versions doesn't have her bodybuilder physique. Out of the artists, Amanda Conner stands out the most in the JSA Classified storyline. Conner gives her a more modern look. Her version of Power Girl is wonderful to look at. It brings out Johns' story. My favorite part has to be when she explains why she has an opening towards the cleavage area of her costume. The jokes also work in ties of the artwork as well. Also, fantastic cover artworks by both Conner and Adam Hughes.

Love the cover by Adam Hughes
Love the cover by Adam Hughes

Overall: This is a perfect book to understand the origins of Power Girl, both the previous versions and her current incarnation. If you are a fan of Geoff Johns, Amanda Conner, or even a fan of Power Girl, this is a great tradeback to add to collections. 

No Caption Provided


 


Other reviews for Power Girl #1 - Power Girl

    Power Girl Lacks Power Writing 0

    The Story:  Taking place shortly after the events of Infinite Crisis, Power Girl begins to see things that aren't there like enemies attacking her, a plane crashing and the Legion Of Super Heroes attacking her. Power Girl also experiences issues with her powers as well as gaining different ones for a short period of time. She struggles to find her place in this new world and runs into Psycho-Pirate.  My Thoughts:  This was my first venture into the world of Power Girl which was written by Geoff ...

    3 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.