the_mighty_monarch's Men of War #1 - Joseph Rock; Navy Seals: Human Shields, Part 1 review

    Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch

    War in the DCU

    The Good: The cover is REALLY cool, definitely one of my favorites so far. Effective and engaging. 
    The art is really great at being real and gritty without going too far into standard and boring territory. There's an amazing section at the beginning. We see Rock in midst of a battle, and then cut to a meeting with him and 2 higher ranking officials. Rock is firm in his position as one of the men tries to pry some answers out of him. Suddenly something he says catches Rock off guard, his facial expression softens into curiosity, and we see his eyes for the first time, an INTENSELY powerful blue that sticks out like a sore thumb. Realization hits. His eyes haven't been shown until now, and now we see he's been singled out as the main character. In that moment of hesitation, we finally see into his eyes, and catch a glimpse of them man behind them, more than just the nameless soldier he was before. 
    This book captures an interesting spirit that places it in the DCU. For most of the issue, it's a pretty typical (Though VERY well written) gritty war comic. And then the metahumans show up. This is a gritty war comic in a world where metahumans exist. A lot of the tone is still the same, but the scope of the storytelling is changed completely. We're never told who the metas are who interrupted the story, but that's not important. They are simply representations of the world this comic takes place in. It's a very interesting concept with some very solid execution. 
     
    The Bad: This is not a series worth $3.99. The backup story is just an average war story with no demonstrated connection to anything. And it just wasn't very interesting. I had to struggle to get through it to see if it meant anything, and the only time I was interested in the least was the last page, but even then it wasn't all that great. It was pointless and confusing. 
    Not a whole lot really happened, and I can't full tell where this series is trying to go. 
     
    In Conclusion: 4/5 
    This is definitely a very solid new DC comic, and a welcome part of the New 52. I would definitely advise this to anyone looking for something a little different in the 'gritty' category. Nice deep blend of art and writing to set the tone makes a great execution of a great concept.

    Other reviews for Men of War #1 - Joseph Rock; Navy Seals: Human Shields, Part 1

      It's your job to prove me wrong 0

      I am not really sure what to make of this series based off of the first issue.  It is an interesting concept, looking as it does at modern war, a subject which has come to dominate mass media in the past ten years.  The lens here is of course on soldiers in a comic book world though and thus contrasts their experiences alongside some of those of heroes 9Superman makes a brief and blurry appearance).  That having been said though the book is confusing at times as it resorts to cliches (the young ...

      6 out of 7 found this review helpful.

      I think DC needs to MOW down less trees. 0

      The Army anthology is back. The last comic I reviewed with Ivan Brandon in it was Weird War Tales #1 (2010) and I had to reread what I wrote and I felt it was mean in retrospective, but it is true I really can't remember his story since I felt it was the weakest of the anthology and page count could of been a problem. Brandon has more pages in this one and that helps his story introducing Joseph Rock, the Grandson of Frank Rock, better know as Sgt. Rock. The story it self is framed in a strong b...

      4 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.