Character » Knightfall appears in 30 issues.

    An innocent girl who spent time in Arkham Asylum, she now seeks to eradicate crime by killing all criminals.

    Short summary describing this character.

    No recent wiki edits to this page.


    No Caption Provided

    Charise Carnes and her younger brother Emil were born to William and Virginia Carnes, a rich and prestigious family in Gotham City thanks to her father's real estate dealings. He'd bought a large landfill on the bayfront of Gotham and enacted the state's biggest land reclamation right on top of it. William Carnes was no saint though, building his riches with muscle, bribes, and countless judges in his pocket. Charise was aware of her father's corrupt practices, but idolized him all the same. She never thought another man could come close to the admiration she felt for her father, until she met Trevor. He was a kind boy who was the first one she met that didn't seem to care about her family's riches. He certainly didn't, as one night he came to her house with knives and made Charise bind her parents and little brother up with duct tape, after which he took three hours to cut them to pieces "for the lulz", all while Charise was forced to watch.

    Afterwards, reportedly no evidence was found that someone else had committed the slaughter, and so Charise was left as the only suspect. She was found guilty and sent to Arkham Asylum at age 18 due to prison overcrowding. Then there was a massive breakout at Arkham where some of the sickest murderers in the country took guards hostage and "played" with them. Charise survived, but had been forced to watch this brutality for two straight days. This was all what Charise had wanted however. After Trevor had killed her family, she'd realized that there were crimes that prison simply wasn't severe enough for as punishment. She'd hidden the truth of the massacre in order to get sent to Arkham, in order to learn "the craft of madness." She learned everything she could've wanted, especially under the tutelage of James Gordon Jr. while she was in Arkham.

    No Caption Provided

    Now reshaped as she saw fit, Charise used every one of her father's underhanded methods to get herself released from Arkham. She then set to work on saving Gotham from the madness and crime that had permeated it as Knightfall. As Charise Carnes, she would use her family's money to change Gotham for the better with community service programs and urban redevelopment; and as Knightfall, wielding the knives Trevor had used on her family, she and her Disgraced would use whatever means necessary to apprehend, torment, and kill all criminals. She would rule Gotham, and fix what civilization couldn't.


    Knightfall was created by Gail Simone and Alitha Martinez. She first appeared as Charise Carnes in 2012's Batgirl #10, but wasn't formally introduced as Knightfall until the following issue.

    Major Story Arcs

    Knightfall Descends

    Following a charity event for her community service programs, Charise had her Disgraced see whether Batgirl would be willing to join their cause by having them threaten to kill a young carjacker, Ricky, that they'd previously caught in a bear-trap. Batgirl failed the test by saving the young man, after which Katharsis attacked her. Batgirl managed to gain the upper hand over Katharsis, but only until the rest of the Disgraced ganged up on her, and Charise arrived in her Knightfall guise.

    Knightfall presented Batgirl with a formal offer to join her and her Disgraced in their endeavors to completely eradicate crime in Gotham. Batgirl would not agree to killing anyone, and so Charise ordered her Disgraced to kill her. Batgirl put up a good fight, but she was simply outnumbered and wound up being held aloft by her throat by Bonebreaker, while Knightfall prepared to kill her. Detective Melody McKenna suddenly appeared however, and ordered Charise to let Batgirl go. McKenna was a cop who worked for Charise, although she had started questioning her methods as Knightfall, and she now threatened to expose everything she knew if Charise didn't let Batgirl go. Charise let Batgirl and McKenna leave, apparently not considering either of them much of a threat.

    Charise later calls McKenna and orders Batgirl to meet her, telling her that they captured Ricky again and that they'll skin him, gut him, and burn him alive if she doesn't come. Batgirl comes to the agreed location and tangles with the Disgraced again, except she brings McKenna and Batwoman as backup, who handle the Disgraced while Batgirl goes to find Charise. She winds up finding a badly injured Ricky in a cage with another tortured man. She tries to pick the lock, but Charise comes up behind her and stabs her in the stomach.

    Batgirl gets some help from Ricky.
    Batgirl gets some help from Ricky.

    With Batgirl bleeding profusely, Charise lectures her on how it's the fault of people like her that Gotham is overrun with crime. When Batgirl collapses on the floor, she calls Bonebreaker to come dispose of her body, but Batgirl steadies herself and brings the fight to Charise. During the fight, Charise decides to show Batgirl just who she is behind the mask of Knightfall. She tells Batgirl her story: her father's corrupt ways, Trevor's slaughtering of her family, and how she'd chosen to go to Arkham to learn the way of criminals. She also reveals that the other man in the cage with Ricky is in fact Trevor, who's she's been meticulously torturing for the last few months as his punishment. Batgirl is horrified by this and they continue fighting, although she is still dwindling from her stab wound. Charise has the upper hand until Ricky grabs her from inside the cage and gives Batgirl a clear hit. Charise goes down, but mocks Batgirl, telling her that she has more than enough officials in her pocket to stay out of prison, with no cop who would even dare arrest her. Batwoman and McKenna then step in, with McKenna more than willing to be the cop who makes that arrest. Charise still still taunts Batgirl, claiming that she'll tear Gotham apart, but Batgirl firmly accepts the challenge.

    Two days later, Charise's Disgraced are seen visiting some of Batgirl's latest rogues: Mirror, Gretel, and Grotesque in their respective prisons, offering to get them out of prison, if they'll simply kill Batgirl for them.

    Powers & Abilities

    Knightfall is masterfully devious tactician, able to easily go from her facade of a vulnerable young girl to her true, ruthless self. She has a vast network of lawyers, judges, and other officials at her beck and call - due to anything ranging from blackmail to bribery. Her family's fortune gives her a great amount of capital for her endeavors, a fortune she maintains through business deals and charity events. She is also a formidable combatant with the two knives she wields that were used to slaughter her family.


    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.