mechanisticmoth's I, Vampire #1 - Tainted Love review

    Avatar image for mechanisticmoth

    I Could Eat You Art, but Your Writing Leaves a Bad Taste

    I care nothing for vampires. They seem like an easy mystical creature to write. No exceptional hang ups – they bite, they suck, they prey, and they’re sexy. Frankly, though, I don’t find the sex appeal. I do not see how living forever could ever be something someone would want especially at the expense of other people.

    And, to be brutally honest, this comic did not change my opinion on vampires.

    Now, let’s take a step back for a minute (as we so often do in my reviews).

    I, Vampire is probably one of the more risky ventures for DC during their relaunch. Sure, we’re still on the cusp of Twilight mania, but it has absolutely no recognizable characters to hinge itself upon. Sure, the writing makes reference to some of the superheroes, but it seems rather forced.

    It’s a cool idea (despite being overly done): different factions of vampires with different ideologies on their role in the world. Obviously, our protagonist (I’m not sure if he has a name yet (Andrew?)) is on the underdog side of cohabitation while his former lover is on the side of “KILL THE HUMANS AND RULE THE WORLD”. I like how there’s this underground fight going on underneath the superheroes’ noses. But, putting vampires into a superhero world is just a little much. Luckily, they’re more of a traditional vampire who can change into all sorts of shapes.

    That gets us to the writing by Joshua Fialkov. It is godawful. There’s a conversation that runs throughout the issue, but I can’t tell which conversation it’s coming from since there’s flashbacks to at least three other conversations (possibly the same one but it's so hard to tell even with the color shading). Let alone, the conversation is the typical “I love you but what are you doing” “We have to take back control” “But can’t we just go around being cool” “No, we can only be cool if we are super sexy and take over the world one bite at a time” “Well, I’m not going to let that happen” “Too bad, I’m amassing an army” “Well… fine” “Don’t worry, you look sexy when you pout” *SMEK* …Actually, I think I wrote the conversation better right there.

    Now, what you should buy this issue for is the art. Andrea Sorrentino on pencils and Marcelo Maiolo on colors make a fantastic team. Plus, I think this comic is the only one with a woman on pencils for The New 52. So, show your support. But, really, it’s fantastic. Fantastic in not that sort of way where it means “great” but in that way that she constructs some really amazing, stark, imaginary imagery. This world is dark and moody with neutral tones. She can handle the vampires as humans and then as beasts equally well and there’s this frantic sense of detail. As a bonus, NEARLY EVERYONE HAS THEIR SHIRT OFF.

    So, overall, the comic gets 2.5 stars instead of just 1 because of the fantastic art pulling double duty. I feel like next issue could get better without the moody me against the world set up.

    Other reviews for I, Vampire #1 - Tainted Love

      What? They Skipped Over the Sex? Did They Not Get the Memo? 0

      I, Vampire proves itself to be the sleeper hit of the week, presenting a chilling and dark take on the relatively unexplored area of vampires in the DC Universe. Andrew Bennett returns as the centuries old vampire standing between his people and humankind's destruction.This easily had to be the most maligned of the New 52 when the announcements first rolled out, and I can't say it was all entirely baseless. Can you really blame anyone for reacting badly to this cover and the promotional material...

      10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

      Looks Can Be Decieving 0

      The Good: Let's see here. I see a cover with sexy vampires wearing little clothing and appearing very shiny. I'm worried. Let's open this up and... HOLY CRAP THIS IS AWESOME. The artwork is DARK. CREEPY. INSANE. Yes, love is actually a huge part of the story here. But as the title says, it's tainted love. Corrupted and impure. We've got a pretty standard vampire hero wanting to help mankind, but he's emotionally torn between his compassionate nature and his powerful love for someone who's rapidl...

      9 out of 9 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.