Too old, uninspired.

As far as vocal roles go then yes, he's a great Hal. I don't think he should play Hal in live action unless he is intentionally supposed to be an older gentleman

He's said before in interviews he's too old for the role.

Maybe they could do classic Hal when he had white streaks in his hair since as others have stated he's an older gentleman

I dunno, he never struck me as Jordanesque, despite the calls for Fillion to be casted as Hal.

Nerds cast Nathan Fillion as everyone.

If only... if only