@Avenging-X-Bolt said:
It's not irrelevant we have the luxury of hindsight and can use it to see a different view. Hal chose to leave Oa, but kept the Ring, thus he was still a GL, especially since Sinestro and others were so scared that they were looking for other means to win. Hal's a coward IYO but Sinestro was running scared to Yellow because he was at his wits end, yet a rookie GL defeats who he can't.
and once again your using one persons mistakes to justify anothers and that doesnt fly. ive conceded that Sinestro gave up but i dont see how that justifys Hal's actions.
Because he can't be Mr. Cocky and perfect the entire movie, he has to be down before he can pick himself up, his character has to be relateable. There's very few people who would just soldier on after being insulted as harshly as Hal was, he had issues and worked through them.
No ones asking him to be cocky and perfect, they're asking him not be be a quitter. Hal doubted himself a great deal of (have you read Dennis O'neil's GL series) times in the comics but he still kept at it. its not called being perfect.
@Avenging-X-Bolt said:
Last i checked Kilowog said that humans wee self centered and that they thought they were the center of the universe. i would qualify that as an insult.
I would suggest watching that scene again. Yes, Kilowog does say that, but watch what happens after he does. He proceeds to teach and train Hal (tough but fair), not sit there and rant about how Abin will never be replaced, and that nobody is worthy of Abin's ring, and how Abin was the best of them all, that Lantern's never show fear. The Ring chose Hal, apparently Sinestro believes he knows more than the ring, when clearly he didn't.
i know what happened in the scene. my comment stands. i even said quite plainly in the original comment that Kilowog "sucked it up and did his job" which you either actively ignored or didnt process.
@Avenging-X-Bolt said:
They have transports like the kind in First Flight when Hal got kicked out of the Corps. Hal said I quit. when Carol talked to him about being a GL Hal speciffically he quit which is why she got was disappointed in him. he essentially quit the corps and stole a GL ring. im not against Hal having a character arc, i would just like one that displays his actual character. I understand that Hal was going through a tough time but he doesnt mean he didnt quit.
But not in the Green Lantern movie, I don't believe the other Lanterns would have allowed Hal to leave if they thought he wasn't coming back. I'm not totally sure but perhaps Parallax was already on his way to Earth around then? Maybe not.
Its called a plot hole. Pure and simple.
" I'm done. He's right, I'm only human. We're not ready to defend the universe. Up until a few days ago, we thought we were the only ones IN the universe."
Sounds like Hal was just doubting himself, and that's perfectly reasonable considering humans had no idea there was alien life out there. Should Hal have stood up to Sinestro more, sure, but more than anything Hal's confidence needed to be repaired, and it was later.
still quitting. if you take a test, leave in the middle because its too hard then still considered quitting. even if you have a talk with your mommy (or Carol in this case) and decided to try again.
it sounds like we should just agree to disagree.
Log in to comment