With Sean Cassidy and Emma Frost in New York for the weekend, the students decide to spend the evening watching videos. As Everett and Jonothan make snacks (with disastrous results), Angelo arrives with a stack of slasher movies, much to the chagrin of the girls.
After the movie marathon, Jubilee tries to sleep on the couch but awakens to noises. She and Angelo witness Paige being killed by Bastion (who looks like Norman Bates in drag), and Jubilee realizes she's dreaming. The nightmare continues, as she watches her teammates murdered by Sabretooth/Freddie Krueger, Omega Red/Jason and Emplate/Leatherface.
Jubilee finally forces herself to wake up only to find her fellow students planning to scare her, but her fury forces them to abandon the prank.