Who writes Gambit the best?

Avatar image for jrock85
#1 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
  1. Chris Claremont
  2. Fabian Nicieza
  3. Marjorie Liu
Avatar image for mechanical_ape
#2 Posted by Mechanical_Ape (628 posts) - - Show Bio

I've always like Fabian Nicieza's portrayal of Gambit, but all three of those have done well with him. I think Mike Carey could do a lot with him if he wanted to. What little he has done with the character has been pretty good. Also, the main character in his novels reminds me of Gambit in many ways, so I'm sure he could manage it.

Avatar image for jrock85
#3 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@Mechanical_Ape: 
I agree that Mike Carey could do a lot more with Gambit but the problem is that its all about Rogue when it comes to him.
Avatar image for journey_into_chaos
#4 Posted by Journey Into Chaos (352 posts) - - Show Bio

I dunno. Too many writers.
Avatar image for jrock85
#5 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@Journey Into Chaos:
Who's portrayal of him do you like the best?
Avatar image for eyesblind
#6 Posted by natejoseph09 (137 posts) - - Show Bio

I'd say that currently Marjorie Liu is easily his best writer. He's the fun Remy, who's not caught up in Rogue buisiness and her old lover.

Then possibly Victor Gischler as it's good to seem him in a team environment,

............ and way at the back is Mike Carey.

Avatar image for jrock85
#7 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@natejoseph09:
Yep. You post on Marvel.com all the time, right?
Avatar image for eyesblind
#8 Posted by natejoseph09 (137 posts) - - Show Bio

Yep, but not for a long time tho.

Avatar image for jrock85
#9 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@natejoseph09:
Milligan was the worst.
Avatar image for mercy_
#10 Posted by Mercy_ (94829 posts) - - Show Bio

I can't say that I've read too much Gambit. I read some of Carey's X-Men run (Golgotha and Bizarre Love Triangle) and didn't care for all the Rogue/Gambit drama (I've made my feelings on the two of them known before). I didn't like how Rogue-centric he was in that run, I absolutely adore the camaraderie that he has with X-23 and the way that Marjorie Liu writes him. 

Avatar image for jrock85
#11 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Dark Huntress:
Marjorie Liu's portrayal of Gambit has gotten an overwhelmingly positive reaction from Gambit fans (at least the ones I talk to). Carey, unfortunately, always portrays him as Rogue-centric; much to the dismay of many readers. Even in Age of X, he was fawning over Rogue. Above all else, Carey bringing back the "Death" thing is what really put him in my dog house.
Avatar image for mercy_
#12 Posted by Mercy_ (94829 posts) - - Show Bio
@jrock85: I finally got around to reading the first trade the other day. I have to say that it may be one of my top three-five books right now. It's really really good and is making me love Gambit. Why does the Death powers thing put him in the dog house? (Not asking to spark an argument, more out of ignorance than anything else). 
Avatar image for darkchild
#13 Posted by Darkchild (42590 posts) - - Show Bio
@jrock85 said:
"
  1. Chris Claremont
  2. Fabian Nicieza
  3. Marjorie Liu
"
these three are the best in writintg him

i think it goes in this order

Chris made Gambit, Fab the Man Nicieza continued the awesomeness. Liu could either totally f#ck em or make him look absolutely awesome an continue it for years. Im giving it another year before i make my decision on Liu
Avatar image for jrock85
#14 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Dark Huntress:
Gambit becoming a Horseman of Apocalypse should have never happened in the first place, which is why Milligan is universally reviled by Gambit fans. Carey bringing it back was not a good way to endear himself to us. Its basically just a rehash of Angel's story and it wasn't needed for Gambit.
Avatar image for jrock85
#15 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@Darkchild:
I'm fairly confident in Liu right now. She and Chuck Kim are the only writers who have done him any real justice since CC in X-treme X-Men.
Avatar image for mechanical_ape
#16 Posted by Mechanical_Ape (628 posts) - - Show Bio

I think something good could have been done with Gambit's Death persona, unfortunately the story has been left to linger far too long. At this point, I'd prefer to see a quick and simple solution to deal with it, since it doesn't seem like it's leading anywhere significant.

Avatar image for jrock85
#17 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@Mechanical_Ape said:
" I think something good could have been done with Gambit's Death persona, unfortunately the story has been left to linger far too long. At this point, I'd prefer to see a quick and simple solution to deal with it, since it doesn't seem like it's leading anywhere significant. "
Its become a cancer to the character.
Avatar image for eyesblind
#18 Edited by natejoseph09 (137 posts) - - Show Bio


I think once Carey sorts out the Gambit/death thing, then other writers can utilize it in their stories properly.

 It might work out well for him.

Avatar image for jrock85
#19 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@natejoseph09:
If Carey actually does make "Deathbit" compelling, it will surprise the hell out of me.
Avatar image for eyesblind
#20 Edited by natejoseph09 (137 posts) - - Show Bio


@jrock85

 I bet we'll see how Rogue and Magneto react to the Deathbit situation.

With Gambit not even having an opinion.

Avatar image for jrock85
#21 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio

  Here's a couple of  Q&A's from a recent Mike Carey interview:


You've got an interesting dynamic with this team in that each character has a connection with at least one other character. Xavier and Magneto have been both best friends and arch-enemies, Legion is Xavier's son, Gambit and Rogue were in a romantic relationship and we understand that Frenzy and Gambit also have a past relationship?

Yes. They've fought each other in the past, but they've shown interest in each other, too. Fabian Nicieza, back in the day, was certainly sowing seeds for a romantic entanglement and we've gotten the occasional glimpse here and there. So the team dynamic is a complicated one.

There are a lot of tensions and conflicting agendas. Just like my first X-Men team, you could argue that this will be a group that contains the seeds of its own destruction. It's fairly unstable and there are people pulling in different directions. As we'll see in the first arc, the people that have the most at stake in this team are Frenzy and Legion. There's a sense in which Legion's presence is crucial to everything that happens. At least, it's fairly crucial to how the first two arcs play out and what the goals are.

 

Rogue is no longer the leader of the new team in "Legacy." Is that because she's reluctant to lead a team again after her experiences in your "X-Men" run?

What we'll see in issues #250-251 is that Professor X is the guy who proposes this team and sets up its parameters. But yes, there are tensions. At least one person in the group is working slightly at cross purposes to the others. The other area of tension, of course, is that we've got Rogue, Gambit and Magneto working and fighting side by side. So there's the potential for some edgy interactions there.



I really hope he consulted Nicieza before addressing this Gambit/Frenzy relationship. Also, Am I the only one who's tired of the love triangles?

Avatar image for spikevalentine
#22 Posted by spikevalentine (174 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm amazed nobody mentioned Jeph Loeb, Howard Mackie, or at least Fabian Nicieza.

Avatar image for jrock85
#23 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio
@spikevalentine
I actually did mention Nicieza in the OP.
Avatar image for tigerstriper
#24 Posted by Tigerstriper (461 posts) - - Show Bio

Fabian Nicieza

Chris Claremont

I'd like to see what Mark Waid could do with him.

Avatar image for jrock85
#25 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio

Glad this got bumped.

Avatar image for jrock85
#26 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio

Can't believe I didn't mention Scott Lobdell.

Avatar image for eyesblind
#27 Edited by natejoseph09 (137 posts) - - Show Bio

Mike Carey

Avatar image for jrock85
#28 Posted by jrock85 (2882 posts) - - Show Bio

@natejoseph09 said:

Mike Carey

LOL

Avatar image for purgy
#29 Posted by Purgy (427 posts) - - Show Bio

Fabian Nicieza Chris Claremont And Liu

Avatar image for x35
#30 Posted by X35 (6464 posts) - - Show Bio

Fabian niceza :)

Avatar image for billy_batson
#31 Posted by Billy Batson (60082 posts) - - Show Bio

Milligan and Carey. Nyah nyah.
BB

Avatar image for healed1337
#32 Posted by healed1337 (42 posts) - - Show Bio

My input for this thread - I'm still new to comics and Marjorie Liu's work in X-23 turned me into a Gambit fan. I've read some of Chris Claremont's work on him, including his introduction. Where did Fabian write Gambit?

Avatar image for purgy
#33 Posted by Purgy (427 posts) - - Show Bio

Fabian did the Gambit solo series. I belive it was the 1st and 2nd one that Fabian wrote.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.