@elpendejo said:
@stormcell: You hate Jean because marvel tries its best to prop her up... yet you like Emma Frost?
Actually, the reason I dislike Jean is for the reasons I stated. Marvel's efforts to prop her up is destroying the canon. I've admitted that Jean Grey should have been categorized an omega mutant at the time it was originally created. I state this because at that time she was one of the few people around who could host the Phoenix Force (it didn't make sense for her to be one of the few unique to be able to host it given that it eats stars for breakfast, something which has nothing to do with TP or TK, but it was canon at the time that she was one of the few). However, once anybody could host it, she should have no longer been an omega.
Now, why do I make this claim? Let's see, I've posted the reasons time and again on this board.
1) Her ability to wield unlimited power was tied to her being able to host the Phoenix Force. Hence, her power levels naturally had very real limits. This is why Sinister created a clone of Jean to procreate with Scott to give birth to Cable and X-Man. The progeny of Jean and Scott would have no upper limits to their psi powers.
2) X-Man has been consistently much stronger than Jean everytime they've met since his conception as a character. In other words, he should knock her out of the "omega" class. Heck, we just saw recently how X-Man dwarfed Jean in power. Are you guys such blind fanboys that you cannot see how this is creating a huge problem with the canon?
3) There are other psis out there besides X-Man who have been much more powerful than Jean when she isn't boosted by the Phoenix Force. Xavier comes to mind immediately (and yes, I consider Emma to be stronger than Jean, but I'm not going to entertain that discussion at this point). So, now what? Marvel is making the claim that Jean without the Phoenix Force is stronger than Xavier eventhough he's always been much more powerful and has the feats to back that?
Given Marvel's track record when they want to prop up Jean, they lessen the power levels of other characters to make her look good. We have seen throughout the years Storm's power levels and mental defenses take a dip whenever she and Jean are on the same team. This was true from the early 90s-the mid-2000s. Conversely, when she and Jean were not on the same team during this period, Ororo's power levels and mental defenses went up. Then, in the 2000s, Magneto's mental defenses have all but disappeared whenever he fights Jean, and now, he has a flawed force-field whereas he used to have a flawless force-field. All of this was done so Jean could pose threat to him in battle. I think Xavier is going to be next on the chopping block for Jean. She doesn't have the feats to prevail against him in a psi-battle, but dollars to donuts she will win if they fight in the future. Putting Jean on this list before Xavier now when hosting the Phoenix Force is no longer a special thing for her is crap writing that totally ignored DECADES of Xavier's canon feats and power levels.
Here's the thing: who wants to read a comic when there is no consistency at all to the power levels and power sets of the characters? Obviously, not too many people with the continually dipping comicbook sales. I mean, really, it's like whomever is the pet character of the writer and/or editor wins at the expense of other characters who have been canonically much stronger.
4) Including Jean, Iceman, Magneto, Exodus, and some of the others on that list devalues it, to be honest. It creates huge loopholes and plotholes as this is a blatant disregard of so much established canon. When future writers come on board, they are going to add their own pet favorites to the list, and some of those additions won't make sense, but because of the inclusion of some of these characters, it will open the door for that.
Again, I have outlined these reasons in my earlier posts.
As for that cry baby picture, the joke's on Marvel, not me. They are the losers in all of this since their actions have led to the downward spiral in sales of their product. I haven't bought an X-Men comic in ages because of the craptastic writing, and obviously the same holds true for hundreds of thousands of other people who used to read the title. Heck, if I remember correctly, didn't Marvel have to file bankruptcy in the mid-1990s? Looking at how they handled X-Men, dollars to donuts they did the same thing to their other titles which led to them going broke from lack of sales.
In the 90s, they kept recycling the same old Grey/Summer clan story tropes from the 80s over and over again, and it got tired. There were other characters on the team that had far greater fan appeal. These other characters are the ones that the base mostly cared to read more about, but the editors and writers tried to force readers to care about the characters they liked rather than who the reader liked...and they paid the price for it.
I mean, they even got so desperate to include Jean and Quire on this list they changed Legion's powerset. He has the exact same powers as Jean (plus his added pyrokinetic abilities), but he's just FAR more powerful than she. So, they just put down for his powerset "power" instead of "psi" or "telepath" or "telekinesis", LOL! They had to do that to make a space for her, Quire, and Exodus...but then they still didn't deal with X-Man, Cable, and Stryfe which leaves a glaring plothole. :::shakes head:::
Anywho, I have to get back to other stuff. Out of time, now.
Log in to comment