I can't pick either because they are both comedic games that make me laugh hard. When I played Slenderman it was super unpolished and cut out as soon as your caught, and Amnesia is just LOL!!!! Like the main monster is always comin at ya like "Imma suck yo dick!". The game just makes laugh at how silly the main monster looks with their cute googely eyes! :3
Of the two Amnesia is the better game that has actually been polished.
BloodRayne(PS2/Game Cube/Xbox/PC) or Return to Castle Wolfenstein(PS2/Xbox/PC)?