The Last of Us vs Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption Stomps

RDR2 is better in every possible way. Gameplay, story, character development, pacing and virtually every other category.

Pretty much this. I personally think that The Last of Us is overrated.

Red dead was better.

Red Dead 2

Mismatch.

The one with Arthur Morgan

Red Dead 2.

The most overrated game of all time vs one of the greatest and fairly beloved game of all time.

Tough choice.

Arthur destroys the crying simulator

RDR2 is also overrated.

@takenstew22: nope

It is for me. While still a good game, it feels more like an interactive movie at times (especially with the intro, god that was too long) and the controls can get kind of annoying.

@takenstew22: the controls are quite divisive, you’ll either like it or dislike it. It’s a bit hands on for me to call it an interactive movie imo, Detroit Become Human is more closer to that.

@michaelbn: How would you rank TLOU from 1-10?

Neither. But LOU is overrated nonsense. Too much pathos

@payneintheass: The Last of Us is so overrated.

Red Dead Redemption 2. Both were well made games though.

@payneintheass: 8/10 a great exclusive game with great sale rate for an exclusive. 1 for engaging narrative even though the concept is generic and the only good characters are Joel and David. 1 for beautiful lighting and forests' saturation. 0.5 for audio design especially in wilderness. 0.5 for the ambiguous ending. 5 for music; more than half of the TLOU wouldn't be as emotional and great without Gustavo's​ amazing soundtrack. TLOU's soundtrack is masterpiece.

@takenstew22: Losing the game of the year and the best action adventure game to Dad of Boi. Not receiving a single nod from Bafta so Boi can win all the awards. Lost to fartnite in Golden joyestic awards. Game Critics completely ignoring the game without a single nomination so that good but not great PS4 spider-man could win. Yeah it's overrated.

The Last of Us is one if not the most overrated game of all time.

@michaelbn: it getting robbed buy credits who care more about trends doesn't mean anything.

God of war is overrated and Fortnite is trash.

Where have you been? RDR2 is praised beyond belief. GoW and Spider-Man PS4 are also incredibly praised and Fortnite is just...Fortnite.

Well, that's the way it is...

I’m sorry but whe TLOU2 comes out.... It will stomp a mud hole into Overrated Redemption 2.

@michaelbn: I’m sorry but God Of War is a better franchise then Red Dead. Better music, story, characters, and villains.

@michaelbn: Thanks for the serious answer.

Based on that, I assume you don´t like Ellie, has that lowered your expectations for Part 2?

@reactor: Good.

@king-ragnar: Eh, wouldn’t say RDR2 is better when it comes to pacing. Not when it’s got both the guarma section and the beginning of part 1 of the epilogue

Anyways, red dead redemption 2 I guess. Although the fact that gamers try to claim both of these games are “overrated” normally tends to mean it’s pretty damn good

TLOU touched me in a way no other game ever has. RDR2 was good, but not on the same level for me.

rdr2 by far.

its also way better than GoW.

the only reason it lost GotY is becouse GoW had more fans.

i cant see any other reason.

GoW > TLOU > Red Dead

I agree TLOU isn’t some sort of ground breaking master piece like a lot of people think it is, but Red Dead was vastly more overrated and jerked off than TLOU ever was.

9/10 seems to prefer RDR2. And I absolutely agree with them.

The Last of Us felt like an interactive movie rather than a video game.

@devoidruby: RDR2 may be slightly overrated but It's still one of the best games of this gen and personally I believe it beats the 1st one.

Haven't play RDR2 yet to make a decision, but if we're comparing the originals, then Last of Us.

I agree red dead does has better game play and graphics but it was created later than last of us in other words It learnt from the last of us mistakes, also the reason why last of us was given that much praise was because it was great at that time and we just hadn't seen better.

Even red dead one holds up to the graphics of the last of us. Red dead two is better. Whilst the last of us was a good cinematic experience, it felt like one long cut scene with linear corridor shooting elements. Whilst red dead 2 is a vast open world, with so much detail, arthur is an interesting character, the choice of multiple endings. I would say the last of us doesn't compare at all to red dead 2.nor does it even compare to red dead redemption, the last of us two vs red dead two would probably be closer, but red dead two still wins, even though the second last of us still hasn't been released.

RDR2

last of us easy

I just got around to playing it a few few months back and it's my fav game along with witcher 3

And before I played witcher or Lou

Rdr 1 was my favourite game

Buuut

Rdr2 to me didn't live up to my nostalgia and personally I prefered mariston's part over Arthur but that's just my opinion

This too btw

TLOU is not overrated

Arthur Morgan solos.

Last of Us...no question in my mind

Now that the hype is over we can finally agree TLOU stomps Red Bore Redemption 2, open world and story keeps it from being a bad game but I swear it's the most boring and slowest title I ever played, I do hope Rockstar realizes how painfully slow to a point of frustration RDR2 is because my god.

I didn't play RDR2 in awhile but I agree. The intro was sooo god damn long it felt way more like a movie than a game.

Red dead 2 stomps. Best game of the last 10 years is doom eternal hands down. Unlike the last non sjw.

@theoneabovelife: 😂😂😂😂

Last of Us stomps

@decaffeinated: Red Dead is still overrated. The Last Of Us is more interesting especially with their variation of infected. Somehow better than most hollywood films about Zombies.

Last Of Us 2 is fanfic. So it doesn’t count.

@theoneabovelife: all great things are overrated.

Including TLOU.