Split or Fight Club ?

Which movie is the better movie about Split Personality ?

While Split is more bizarre, I think Fight Club does better. I don't want to say more because I may give spoilers for both.

Fight Club, even though I still don't care too much for the Project Mayhem stuff.

@scavengerfist: there were a few flaws with fight club that some people overlook.

@ravenvice01: please elaborate, I'd like to know

@scavengerfist: yeah, me too.

@scavengerfist: first obvious flaw was when Edward Norton was beating on himself in front of the bar. Two guys walk up to Edward Norton and ask him as well as brad Pitt if they could join in the fun. The two strangers made eye contact with Edward Norton and an imaginary brad pitt

Fight Club is better.

@ravenvice01: well I always thought that it was a third person perspective but narrated by Norton's character, so that's how he perceived the scene happened

@scavengerfist: you make a valid point in every other instance but that scene I mentioned before kind of shatters Norton's 3rd person perspective

@ravenvice01: yea, I agree it's a flaw. Maybe another thing happened entirely when the men intercepted Norton fighting himself.

@scavengerfist: unfortunately when crafting masterpieces, directors or writers forget key moments and fail in consistency. The latest pirates movie proved that with so many plot holes.

@ravenvice01: oh man, I don't even want to go arguing on that movie. I just didn't feel the lore that happened in there.

@scavengerfist: it's no prob. I like to debate though. U wanna follow each other?

Fight Club is just a better movie in every regard.

@ravenvice01: sure, thanks

That's like asking "what's better, a Big Mac or a Fine Steak?" Split is solid enough thriller but the twist is the only thing that makes it noteworthy. FIght Club is a top 10 movie for me

Fight Club all the way. It's my favourite movie.

The split personality is the worst aspect of Fight Club.

Club overall but for performance, Split is better.

FC is better overall. McAvoy's performance in Split is great though.

FC is more interesting, but I enjoyed Split more.

Split. By a lot. Fight Club is good, but it's not that good.