@warlockmage: No, it's not bullshit, that was how he was designed. It was only 4 and 5 where they started to give him personality. So are you whining about him being bland and whining about them giving him personality? Damned if they do, damned if they don't, I suppose.
EDIT: Figured I'd edit this before I get another post of you flailing wildly at me to tell me how much you hate the character.. This thread isn't about rather or not you like him. This is about 'is he overrated' in that normal lazy CV way of writing OPs that doesn't actually ask a relevant, full question but is just short enough to hold attention.
So, what is he being rated against? What category are we looking at him in? Because, now stay with me here, to be overrated, one must be rated against something.
So... Is he the BEST CHARACTER IN ALL FICTION! ... No. Anyone who believes that is vastly overrated him.
Is he one of the best video game protagonist? I'd say not and anyone who believes that is overrating him.
Is he one of the best FPS video game protagonist? Absolutely. 'But Muh DOOMGUY!' Yes, Doomguy, specifically, the Doomguy [2016] is, imo, the perfect FPS protagonist. But do you know who isn't? The Original Doomguy. Or nearly all FPS protagonist in gaming history. Don't believe me? Try to remember Call of Duty Protagonist 1-415123... Or how about the various battlefield protagonist... No? That is.. odd. How about Resistance? Tell me about how great Nathan Hale was.. Oh, you probably either didn't play that or he didn't stand out all that much compared to the setting... Well.. how about the various Tom Clancy first person shooter protagonist?.. No? Well.. how odd. You know which first person guy really had a personality you remembered from the past? Duke Nukem. Yeah, let that one sink in for awhile. If, at this moment, the joke about a screen with a gun being the FPS protagonist in Wreck-It Ralph just now made sense to you, you have earned a cookie.
This is because Master Chief is a great first person shooter protagonist and has influenced all the good ones that would come after him [Such as 2016 Doomguy, the current pinnacle, but remember that... he came out in 2016, he, as the saying goes, stands on the shoulders of giants, seriously, go back to the old doomguy and tell me his personality without referencing the comics]. Master Chief inspired a lot of FPS protagonist that would come after him. Is he the best? I'd say not anymore. He is still among the best? Yes. I don't even like Master Chief anymore, the Halo Fanboys I've run into over the years have soured me on him, however, I'm not going to deny it just cause I don't like him.
Ergo, this thread is as poorly thought out as most on CV and when someone says 'Is character X overrated?' the first question, and only question, should be 'Overrated in what regard?'
Log in to comment