Poll If you can be transgender, can you also be transracial? (34 votes)
Since people can identify as transgender, following that same logic, should they also be able to identify as transracial?
Since people can identify as transgender, following that same logic, should they also be able to identify as transracial?
Side note: If the consensus is yes, from now on I will identify as a trans-economical individual since I don't like my current financial standing and would like to be classified as a billionaire. If I don't get my wish, you're all bigots.
@dceu_buster: You can be classified as a billionaire for sure, but the actually transition takes time and money. But yeah, go and pay those billionaire taxes.
You can identify as anything you’d like in our postmodern world. Your perspective is your reality. Just don’t get mad when others are unaware of how you identify. Our perspective is our reality, too.
Free N-word pass? I’ll take it hehe
On topic, no chance for either
I agree, but if you allow one, then don't be hypocritical and allow the other one as well.
Free N-word pass? I’ll take it hehe
On topic, no chance for either
There was some weird british kid obsessed with K-Pop who had plastic surgery to looks more asian because he thought he was really asian.
He was called weird and crazy by people with pronouns in their bios on social media.
Can't make this stuff up.
Gender dysphoria is a real phenomenon that's backed by medical science. There is no racial equivalent of that AFAIK.
@cattlebattle: are you implying you have no pronouns sir
There was some weird british kid obsessed with K-Pop who had plastic surgery to looks more asian because he thought he was really asian.
He was called weird and crazy by people with pronouns in their bios on social media.
Can't make this stuff up.
I saw that lmao, hypocrisy at its finest.
Gender dysphoria is a real phenomenon that's backed by medical science. There is no racial equivalent of that AFAIK.
Psychopathy, Narcissism and Sociopathy are all backed by medical science as well, but that doesn't make them right, does it?
@dceu_buster: How desperate do you have to be to compare those 3 with literally questioning your gender lmfao
@dceu_buster: How desperate do you have to be to compare those 3 with literally questioning your gender lmfao
What's the difference between questioning your gender and questioning your race? Both are biologically incorrect.
Edit: I brought up those three because the person's argument for transgenderism was that it's backed by science, well pedofillia is also backed by science, so being backed by science isn't a good argument.
Gender dysphoria is a real phenomenon that's backed by medical science. There is no racial equivalent of that AFAIK.
Psychopathy, Narcissism and Sociopathy are all backed by medical science as well, but that doesn't make them right, does it?
It makes them objectively real things that people experience, which is also true for gender dysphoria, but not for "transracialism". People have no control over being born with ASPD either, so just having it doesn't make someone a bad person. It depends on what you do with it.
Besides, gender dysphoria has nothing to do with psychopathy, and is more linked with depression.
Because race and gender aren’t built the same
Gender is an internal sense on whether we can be a man or a woman.
And unlike gender, race represents that are socially constructed and understood, you can’t inherit gender, its internal and individual to someone. But we do inherit social construct of race, theres more to racial identity than physical appearance. Transitioning races undermines important cultural connections. While there may be history of feminism, these enter people atomically as individuals rather than being inherited from families. There is no heritage to being a man or a woman, any family could have a boy or a girl overtime. Identifying as a race is much more specific.
Theres evidence that gender identity is rooted into our brain at a deep development level
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/hormones-and-the-brain/201608/gender-identity-is-in-the-brain-what-does-tell-us?amp
You cannot be either, though races are quite arbitrary, sex is not. You can have mental disorder sure, but sex is core of being human, and there are only two of them, male and female, which one are you, is decided by biology and written in every nucleus containing cell of your body. Now you have right to identify as anything you wish, and people should not be assholes to you, but do not get angry and attack them if others do not agree with it, you should also not be asshole to them either.
@cattlebattle: Is that the guy who went on Doctor Phil?
Wasn't there a white woman that was able to pass for a black women for many years until someone outed her?
People are already doing this
There was a black woman who identified as a Jew
It's entirely possible to be black and jewish. In jewish culture, once you are birthed from a jewish woman, you are considered a jew regardless of the ethnicity of the father. The converse does not hold true though.
@rudygiuliani: no, I mean, an African American with zero Jewish ties, literally said she is a Jew simply because she identified with them
Yeah why not.
But the thing is, once people start identifying as whatever they want, then it will become a problem.
For instance, when white people start identifying as black, then the woke crowd will implode on themselves.
There’s no such thing as reality anymore we have to live in fanstasyland now.
Yeah why not.
But the thing is, once people start identifying as whatever they want, then it will become a problem.
For instance, when white people start identifying as black, then the woke crowd will implode on themselves.
There’s no such thing as reality anymore we have to live in fantasyland now.
I mean, it’s about separating sex and gender which like it or not are different and are classed as different in scientific literature.
Race and sex are genetic (there are more than two sexes btw). Gender isn’t although there is obviously huge correlation between sex and gender.
@arctika: incorrect I’m afraid. Read a book.
@vengefulshot: Race is a cultural and geographical term. Race is not based on genetics.
There are two sexes for humans. Intersex is an anomaly, not a standard. That doesn’t change the fact that human sex is binary. It’s like saying humans have 10 fingers and toes, even though there are anomalies where people are born with a different number of them. That doesn’t change the fact that humans have 10 fingers and toes. We don’t redefine biologic terms based on anomalies.
If you believe people should be allowed to identify with whatever cultural terms however they choose, then you would need to justify why there is a difference for another cultural term, like race. Specially when race is much less important then gender.
Guys, OP is trolling and trying to undermine a serious issue. Imagine being so tactless and uneducated.
@arctika: incorrect I’m afraid. Read a book.
Wrong. Oh I've read books and had my education thanks. Unfortunately for you, you're incorrect as there is no real, logical book that says there's more than 2 genders lol get a clue...it's called factual biology, there's only 2 genders, male and female period.
if u allow mentally ill people to pick a gender you should be coherent and do the same with people picking a race
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment