@valor_175: thats a NLF i work under the assumption when theirs such a huge stat gap i doubt hax like that would work
Would Genjutsu work on Jiren ?
"Could Professor X use TP on Jiren?"
Heyy I said that already //:
Then again I was just copying you so knock yourself out :P
"Can Martian Manhunter use TP on Jiren?"
"Can Despero use TP on Jiren?"
"Can Jean Grey use TP on Jiren?"
And before anyone tries to make the idiotic assertion that I'm comparing genjutsu to the aforemention characters' TP, stop. But asking whether or not Jiren can resist something he hasn't shown resistance to, and imply he isn't susceptible to said thing solely due to being in a separate tier is downright vacuous.
I understand he's powerful, but mental attacks like TP and genjutsu affect your psyche, and thus have no bearing on physical strength/speed/durability/energy prohection. Just because a guy can benchpress 500 more pounds than you doesn't mean he can see through illusions or combat on a mental plane. They have 0 relation to each other in cross universe battles. And scaling hax resistance to weaker characters because said character has reissted it is fallacious.
@valor_175:so anyone without tp resistance would get beat with genjutsu
also op does not specify what kind of genjutsu as only ocular and sound genjutsu works without chakra
@thenewguysnm1: Well, yes, anyone without TP resistance or stuff like reality warping would get affected by Genjutsu. The No-Limits Fallacy doesn't apply to this situation, it dictates that you shouldn't assume an ability/character/whatever has no limits just because it hasn't shown any, which is completely irrelevant to this discussion as Genjutsu has shown clear limits, Jiren just isn't beyond said limits.
@hittheassasin: fair enough though if its basic genjutsu it shouldn't work on jiren as he has no chakra
@valor_175:so anyone without tp resistance would get beat with genjutsu
also op does not specify what kind of genjutsu as only ocular and sound genjutsu works without chakra
Jiren would kill any genjutsu user before they could use it.
@thenewguysnm1: Not going to get into the whole "genjutsu requires chakra" debate, I haven't read Naruto in forever and thus I can't make a convincing argument in favour of either position.
@hittheassasin: no i mean just regular genjutsu not ocular
@thenewguysnm1: Genjutsu does not require chakra . And it is not specific to any one or two kinds of genjutsu (ocular or sound) .
In the chuunin exams Kabuto puts the people in the stands in a sleep genjutsu which proves that any genjutsu can work on people without chakra .
Jiren would kill any genjutsu user before they could use it.
I agree wholeheartedly but that's not what the OP's asking.
@adi_frost: everyone in NV has chakra all kabuto did was genjutsu people with chakra not people without
@thenewguysnm1: ? Chakra must be created first in order to make ninjutsu or special actions like wall running etc. so nope. They had not chakra during that moment. ? Still Genjutsu works on people without chakra by feats and statements.
I'll give $10.000 if someone proves (or a statement) that Genjutsu works ONLY ? with chakra and can't ? work without it. Nope, Jiraiya statement says A POSSIBILITY to put a Shinobi under Genjutsu. Don't try to f**k me ?
We don't know if jiren is immune to genjutsu but all we know is he would obliterate the spite out of the naruto verse with a glare. The rest of the hst verse would as well be obliterated from said glare.
@thenewguysnm1: Not really . Everyone has the ability to CREATE chakra . They need to train to be able to mix physical and spiritual energy to create chakra .Normal humans don't have chakra in their body all the time . There is no reason to assume they would cause there are on panel CHARTS and explanation stating that chakra needs to be created first , it is not just naturally present .
Jiren would kill any genjutsu user before they could use it.
I agree wholeheartedly but that's not what the OP's asking.
And I wasn't replying to OP.
Jiren would kill any genjutsu user before they could use it.
I agree wholeheartedly but that's not what the OP's asking.
And I wasn't replying to OP.
Then you're off-topic.
Linking @westwood_trevor blog about this Genjutsu does not require chakra not sure why ppl are arguing you need chakra to be genjutsu'd when we allow the Flashes using their hax which only originates and exists in DC the speedforce or Fairy Tail chars being able to use magic when their powers come from a magic particle ethernano which only exists in FTverse and without it no magic. Seriously that is double standards.
On topic: Does Jiren has TP resistance ? He does not. Gets genjutsu'd. If he does then he can resist it.
@jashro44@jedixman@rogueshadow@juiceboks This is a bait thread and it's not a battle.
Linking @westwood_trevor blog about this Genjutsu does not require chakra not sure why ppl are arguing you need chakra to be genjutsu'd when we allow the Flashes using their hax which only originates and exists in DC the speedforce or Fairy Tail chars being able to use magic when their powers come from a magic particle ethernano which only exists in FTverse and without it no magic. Seriously that is double standards.
On topic: Does Jiren has TP resistance ? He does not. Gets genjutsu'd. If he does then he can resist it.
It's a matter of bias-hate.
Not long ago I've argued with a guy about the "Genjutsu factor"; he told me --->"yes, I know well that Genjutsu works without aiming chakra and someone without chakra can be affected. . . but I don't like this result, I don't like that a Naruto character can beat someone from another manga with Genjutsu and I don't like Naruto's Genjutsu in general. So Genjutsu can't work. Fact".
In other words if you're unlucky and find the Naruto hater or the biased one. . . Genjutsu will never work for him, even with every kind of proof, feat and statement. Sad but true.
However don't want to argue in this intentional bait-flame war thread.
Jiren would kill any genjutsu user before they could use it.
I agree wholeheartedly but that's not what the OP's asking.
And I wasn't replying to OP.
Then you're off-topic.
So unless I reply to OP I am off-topic? A topic isn't a linear discussion, it branches into different on-topic discussions to support the main discussion. That is how communication between humans work, maybe you haven't learned that in the second grade yet.
The one who is trying create off-topic content more then anyone here right now is you.
@jashro44@jedixman@rogueshadow@juiceboks This is a bait thread and it's not a battle.
https://comicvine.gamespot.com/profile/westwood_trevor/blog/naruto-why-genjutsu-works-on-people-without-chakra/132475/
OT: bait/not battle thread. @jashro44 @juiceboks
This is a bait thread. Why are so many people falling for it?
@jashro44@jedixman@rogueshadow@juiceboks This is a bait thread and it's not a battle.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment