Wonder Woman or Logan - Best Film?

Logan

WW was good but not THAT good

Was it better than the other DC movies?

Yes easily imo better than a load of mcu ones too

Nothing major just certain things like pacing of the film, emotional connection to the characters. Logan was just consistently amazing in most aspects, it's not a knock on WW just Logan had things locked down like the acting of Jackman and Stewart who we already had an emotional connection with their performances were amazing, the way the story was told and Logan's and Professor X's character arc. Gal Gadot had a great performance and was a great Wonder Woman which shuts up the doubters but it wasn't the level of Logan which I think was probably up there with one of the best acting performances in a CBM. Logan just nailed all aspects incredibly well for me. I rank Logan pretty high in terms of CBM's though

Logan has almost a decade of character building.. the two movies shouldnt be compared.

@thorthunder98: Sweet. Can't wait to watch it.

Will know tomorrow

Wonder Woman, I don't consider Logan a superhero film. It for all intents and purposes felt more like a last of us movie than a Wolverine movie with a dash of Xmen.

@thorthunder98: I can't spoiler block on mobile so bare with me.

I'd say Wonder Woman had much more emotional connection with the characters than Logan. The saddest part about Logan was Charles' death. Wonder Woman and Steve Trevor has one of the best on screen chemistry since The Amazing Spider-Man 2. When Diana goes full beast mode, it was well placed and earned. There was a missing connection between Laura and Logan which made Logan's death a tad awkward.

@monsterstomp: I can agree about Steve and Diana's relationship being really compelling. But I don't think it's fair to compare with Logan given how we have built up a connection with the x-men characters over multiple films which is why I was more emotionally connected to Logan and Charles. Though I can kinda agree about Logan-Laura relationship, but Logan's death was done incredibly emotionally well for me.

Logan stomp, one is a typical but good comic book origin movie, and a other one is a gut wrenching film with Oscar worthy performances that will be remembered fondly as time pass and will withstand the test of time.

WW was pretty good, but I have no idea why it has half of the votes. Logan is just better

Honestly it is close but X-24 was such a bad stain on an otherwise complete movie. REDACTED on the other hand was done pretty well, so I'm going WW.

Logan is best

Diana wreck

Wonder Woman was awesome but it shouldn't be compared to Logan, it's not a question.

Wouldn't put it anywhere close to Logan. Wonder Woman was an amazing movie though.

Logan.

Logan.

Womder Woman film for sure

Logan was a better film imo.

Not a fair comparison. There's a fifteen year buildup for Logan. She's just starting out, ffs.

@ganon15 I know that Logan will be held in higher esteem and I might just lose any credibility I have for saying this, but I honestly think Wonder Woman is a better movie.

Logan is a very good movie, but it isn't superb. Yes, it has 15 years worth of emotional connection and fantastic performances from Jackman and Stewart (acting is the only thing Logan has on WW, I guess), but it's still a flawed movie that people praise as complex because it's "dark" and "gritty", and Jackman's last film. In terms of character development, Mangold should've thought twice before letting Laura be mute for 2/3rds of the film. She's acting like a punk for most of the movie saying nothing, then all of a sudden... 'daddy'? And yeah, I know people are gonna say yeah, but she always looked up to him and read books about him and shit but this is a classic case of telling instead of showing. Compare this to Wonder Woman, where we get little conversations such as the scene in Themyscira ("I'm above average"), the boat scene, the fire scene... by the time they kiss/sleep with one another, it felt earned, and by the time Diana scrutinises Steve and tells him she lost faith in humanity, I almost cried because these are two characters I watched bond throughout the entire movie.

As for the protagonist themselves, we care about Logan... because the past 15 years of X-Men films got us attached to the character. Wonder Woman on the other hand, had the task of establishing a character from (technically) the ground up and instead of crumbling under the weight, Patty Jenkins created the most real protagonist in a superhero movie. Yes, Logan is a western, and yes, it's "grittier" than WW, but why is Diana's worldview being challenged any less genius than what was done in Logan? Because that movie had 15 years of build up? We understand Diana's ambitions, motivations, aspirations, drive, naivety, and we're alongside her in her journey into becoming a hero that understands that "yes, mankind is plagued by war and terror, but there is so much more to them then that."

@thorthunder98: the fck r u talking about? making it sound like Logan is some masterpiece. it was a good movie but it's no WW .

Hard choice. I'll go with WW because it was great and still felt like a superhero movie.

Gonna go with Logan.

Logan

Logan for me, not to say Wonder Woman isn't also great though.

WW .

There are these things called opinions.

so much this. stop making posts for the sake of making posts. they are apples and hand grenades...

Logan.

Logan FTW

Logan and it isn't close.

And ya know I could reverse it on you but I recognise you have an opinion and am not gonna attack you for it soo...

To be honest I think both Wonder Woman AND Logan are a bit overrated, they're good but not as good as they're cracked up to be.

Logan heres why Wonder woman seems so amazing because its the only good movie in the dceu and its the first successful superhero movie as a female. Logan was a great example of redemption. Redeeming himself from the first two wolverine movies. both are great but logan wins (mostly feminists overhype wonderwoman)

@agent41: WW is your average superhero origin story, a good one, but there better ones.

@agent41: its not fair logan has the upperhand because we are all attached to him its like asking who do we like the new kid or one of our team members we have known for years so yeah it shouldnt be compared but people are gonna do it anyways lmao

Logan no contest.

@stoneyalex: tbh logan is one of the few only good fox films as well.