Will Artificial Intelligence replace us powerscalers?

Nah that's too objective

I… hope not

Now tell him which experts it is talking about

Needs more time. AI just takes info from other sources as far as I know.

If the majority of sources say Superman wins, that's what it will tell you.

I wish

In the future maybe. Currently? No way.

AI is certainly less biased than humans but debating specific results (beyond "anything can happen" or "character x wins"), still requires: analysing feats, arguing if certain feats are outliers or not, arguing why a anti-feat is or isn't valid, interpreting statements and trying to prove they should be taken seriously, arguing how the stats and abilities of one character would match against the other and many more...

You don't need to have any qualifications to be a powerscaler but our capacity (as human beings), to react and interpret different situations and social cues on the fly is still superior to the most advanced AI (for what I know), not to mention capacity to gather useful information by yourself without using the bad.

Having said that, AI is more than capable of replicating "X character wins" or "it's subjective/it depends" answers.

It needs more time. As of now, AI just takes info from other sources and sites.

I dont think they can make a judgement without getting it from another website

That was way too nice if it is just grabbing it from the internet.

Couldn't have said it better

It would be hilarious of Comicvine just became populated with AI debating and insulting eachother.

Bump

The AI would be more fair and balanced than any battle board debater. But it’s not likely to replace people yet

Eventually yes

You act like Comic Vine isn't like that already.

@superdarth: True but the AI would hopefully be more creative.

In the 90’s people thought we’d have flying cars and sky police.

We are still arguing over whether or not it’s ok for a man to like another man.

If you think Ai will take over power scalers, you are getting your hopes up.

Bump

LMAO No Artificial Intelligence On This Solar System can replace @rajjarsalt .

Well they definitely seem better than 90% of "debaters" I've seen.

@krisbishop said:

This was ChatGPT’s response to Ichigo Vs Naruto..

They’re not replacing us any time soon.

@mr-yes: Not saying they're gonna replace us, but that answer is still more thought out and eloquent than most Ichigo vs Naruto arguments I've seen.

@mr-yes: want to ask that AI tho, any link??

OT: Maybe in the future, But not now

@mangacomics69 said:

Just google chatGPT

Bump

Hopefully soon enough

Current "AI" are just chatbots programmed to retrieve and format information quickly and lace the answer they provide you with the values of their programmers as can be seen above. At least the bot will own up to its errors when called out on it ( thought at some point in the future, it'll simply lie to you instead ).

I don't think the data sets that exist for powerscaling are objective and cohesive enough to teach an AI, even though it would be technically possible in the abstract.

AI's don't form deterministic understanding, and exist only as a mathematical model - the reliability of this model is wholly dependent on providing reliable data, or at the very least criteria for a successful improvement in model performance, in order to train the model. People within powerscaling communities don't agree on the answers to things, so it would probably have to work on a consensus basis I guess. It is a task especially fraught with subjectivity, requires the ability to decipher feats in multiple mediums/art styles, and also requires assessment of something entirely dependent on human decision making - that is writing itself. A writer could perhaps reduce AI accuracy by simply making inconsistent or non-sensical feats - Aleister destroying a non-existent space, for example.

That said, anything is possible, and maybe we could make a powerscaling AI. I do think the undertaking would be totally wasted on such a trivial task, however.

A.I will never have the passion to consistently make bad faith arguments, use straw mans, poor power scaling and shitty Calcs to defend its favorite character in an online argument, before tossing out a few petty insults after gettingdebunked, disappearing for a week, then making an excuse about real life problems and "I don't spend all my time online".

Souless A.I just doesn't have the capabilities for this. We can not be replaced.

Lmao.

LLMs would no-diff powerscalers. Powerscalers are pretty terrible already

Not missing much if AI does.

Seems like such a waste of tech

Not a chance.

AI will replace everybody

We should be careful with AI but sadly I fear we're going to learn the hard way.

I think in the future, power scalers will use AI to help them with their answers or as an additional tool...and yes, I think AI could replace power scalers in the far future. AI, in the future, can feed on a gigantic amount of comic book/manga data in mere seconds whereas even the best powerscaler humans need years to get that same data...so AI will eventually be used to answer these questions, I think.

It said DCEU Superman would tank the Marvel Comics Necrosword and said DCEU Cheetah would defeat Oblivion. It’s got a long way to go. LOL

I also asked it to come up with a rebuttal to a comment I got, and wrote a rebuttal that went into detail about why personally attacking people battle scaling is bad (It got that part right), and ignored the rest of the comment. LOL