I've been looking up a lot of comic book history, and realized that people REALLY think Superman is lame. So, I wanted to talk about it...
Superman is the most enduring superhero of all time. With that, he has the most pressure to be consistent; a pressure not shared as extremely by peers Batman and Spider-Man. The reason for this is simple: Superman is DC'S corporate icon. It's the same reason why Mickey Mouse isn't messed with. (If only Disney did that with their classic films).
But wait, isn't Spider-Man Marvel's corporate icon? Why is he able to be messed with? I'll tell you why:
HE HAS AN AMAZING SUPPORTING CAST (pun not intended)
With Spider-Man and Batman, they are great concepts for characters by themselves. One is a teen superhero who deals with relatable troubles, and the other is a rich playboy who is secretly a crime fighting, Bat-dressed ninja with a gadget for every situation. These concepts stand on their own, just like Superman's; but when you add supporting characters and rogue galleries that directly relate to the heroes, you get a complete and engaging world. Superman is missing this for the most part. THAT'S the real reason why we think he's lame.
This is also why writers have such a hard time writing him. With Batman and Spider-Man, there's an established, intimate connection with their supporting cast and rogue's gallery, which makes it easy for writers to come up with fresh and unique stories for them. Superman, again, does not have this.
Imagine if you take 80% of Batman's rogue's gallery and supporting cast away from him, and leave everything else the same. That's what you get with Superman. I mean, yes; you have Martha (WHY DID YOU SAY THAT NAME), Jonathan Kent, Lois, The Daily Planet, Perry White, Jimmy Olsen, Zod, Lex, Bizarro, Brainiac, and Darkseid, but that's pretty much it. Who gives a FLYING FUCK about the Parasite? (Haha, "flying" fuck...Okay, I'll leave now).
Though, Superman doesn't just have an incomplete supporting cast and rogue's gallery that is interesting -- he has an incomplete connection to them. Besides Lois, Lex, his parents, and maybe Zod and Bizarro; where is his intimate connection to the people around him that make them arguably more interesting than him? Like, what is his dynamic with Darkseid other than a good guy versus a bad guy who needs Bosley?
TL;DR: We think Superman is lame because he isn't connected to his supporting cast like Batman and Spider-Man.
Log in to comment